The price is far more than I’ll ever be able to pay. But there all sorts of wonderful things to be enjoyed, not least the radio sessions and the TV appearances.
A real labour of love.
Why doesn’t someone open a Bonzo Dog Museum? That would draw the crowds in!
The format is “persona non grata” for one or two CD sets, but for a release like this it’s a case of how many of the little shiny things can you fit in a box. What a bizarre way to run an industry!
What does the Bonzo vinly completist do? Just hold his nose and lump on?
It’s about music in the end, not format. You seem to hate vinyl, others like it. Most people with record players will also have CD players. In fact it’s possible to see benefits in both formats (and also downloads and streaming). Funnily enough, given your prejudices you are like a stuck record making the same point over and over again.
Given the regularity with which they’re churning out lavishly packaged box sets with eye-wateringly-high prices to match, record companies/copyright owners/artists must surely realize they’re shouting out ‘time on your glasses’ in the last chance saloon.
And before someone says, don’t like/can’t afford it, don’t buy it, I’ve bought more than my fair share of boxes in the past and I am sure I ain’t the only punter who’s saying enough is enough.
Recently came ascloseasthis to buying EC’s Armed Forces box and Neil Y’s over-priced A3 until I came to my senses.
Likewise, camethisclose to buying Mind Games (not the $$$$$ box with full size replica of YO’s perspex sculpture thing etc) but the £120-odd box set, before remembering I never much liked that album. Yet to read all the marketing around it, you’d think it was a long lost hybrid of Plastic Ono Band and Revolver.
After buying a few of the original albums (Gorilla being the way in for me, as I suspect it was for many) and then buying The History Of The Bonzos on double LP, followed years later by the three volumes of Cornology in order to have pretty much all of it on CD. And then again, a few more years down the line, I bought the 3 CD comp called A Dog’s Life, to get a couple of extra bits ‘n’ pieces. Finally, tempted by the format and the cheepnis, I picked up the little 5 CD Original Album Series box for a fiver in Fopp one drizzly lunchtime. Is there the remotest chance I will now stump a three-figure sum for this lot? What do you think? That would be the very definition of madness.
Mods, you can free up that 15GB of space you had reserved for my extensive Bonzos Budget Busting Box review after all. For one thing, it wouldn’t be needed for about four years (viz. Jaygee’s reminder of the mandatory six listens) and for another, I came to my senses.
I have bought many CD box sets in the past but I always look for VFM alongside my desire for the artist’s music.
I don’t buy vinyl boxes. In fact I very rarely buy any vinyl at all. It would have to be something that’s unavailable in other formats and even then it would have to pass my VFM test.
My budget is limited and the more recorded music I buy, the less money I have for live music. Live low-cost gigs are my priority these days. Fortunately, there are enough of them occurring in my locality to be able to be choosy about which I go to.
I do buy CDs from artist’s merch tables, when funds allow. I’ve even been known to buy t-shirts.
I’d love it, but I already have Cornology and a couple of old LPs, so it won’t be for me at £250.
I’m intrigued to find put what they have found to put on 17 CDs! They only made 6 albums, and there is some BBC stuff, but where has this all come from?
In the first 20 years if his career Neil Young released about 20 albums. Encompassing the same period he has now put out over 60 other albums in various formats, unreleased ones, live ones, alternate versions etc. And they are all great! *
I really like the Bonzos at their best, but there is quite a lot of patchy stuff even on the 3CD Cornology. God knows what a 17 CD release would amount to.
Just ordered. (JPC offers free shipping – from Germany. Who would refuse that?)
I have a couple of their key tracks on various compilations, and the Beat Club show on DVD, so this is just perfect.
The super deluxe is £450
The price is far more than I’ll ever be able to pay. But there all sorts of wonderful things to be enjoyed, not least the radio sessions and the TV appearances.
A real labour of love.
Why doesn’t someone open a Bonzo Dog Museum? That would draw the crowds in!
Bonzo museum: that’s a great idea. I imagine some of the stage props are kept somewhere and are gathering dust.
Probably less dusty than you think as Roger R S still uses them, previously with 3 Bonzos and a Piano and now with Bonzo Bills.
Recently quite a few of Mr Stanshall’s props have been sold including the giant head.
The format is “persona non grata” for one or two CD sets, but for a release like this it’s a case of how many of the little shiny things can you fit in a box. What a bizarre way to run an industry!
What does the Bonzo vinly completist do? Just hold his nose and lump on?
It’s about music in the end, not format. You seem to hate vinyl, others like it. Most people with record players will also have CD players. In fact it’s possible to see benefits in both formats (and also downloads and streaming). Funnily enough, given your prejudices you are like a stuck record making the same point over and over again.
I know a song about that…
Given the regularity with which they’re churning out lavishly packaged box sets with eye-wateringly-high prices to match, record companies/copyright owners/artists must surely realize they’re shouting out ‘time on your glasses’ in the last chance saloon.
And before someone says, don’t like/can’t afford it, don’t buy it, I’ve bought more than my fair share of boxes in the past and I am sure I ain’t the only punter who’s saying enough is enough.
Recently came ascloseasthis to buying EC’s Armed Forces box and Neil Y’s over-priced A3 until I came to my senses.
Likewise, camethisclose to buying Mind Games (not the $$$$$ box with full size replica of YO’s perspex sculpture thing etc) but the £120-odd box set, before remembering I never much liked that album. Yet to read all the marketing around it, you’d think it was a long lost hybrid of Plastic Ono Band and Revolver.
At £273 for what is one of their most meh albums, this 20th anniversary box set from U2 is just extracting the urine
https://superdeluxeedition.com/news/u2-how-to-dismantle-an-atomic-bomb-20th-anniversary/
After buying a few of the original albums (Gorilla being the way in for me, as I suspect it was for many) and then buying The History Of The Bonzos on double LP, followed years later by the three volumes of Cornology in order to have pretty much all of it on CD. And then again, a few more years down the line, I bought the 3 CD comp called A Dog’s Life, to get a couple of extra bits ‘n’ pieces. Finally, tempted by the format and the cheepnis, I picked up the little 5 CD Original Album Series box for a fiver in Fopp one drizzly lunchtime. Is there the remotest chance I will now stump a three-figure sum for this lot? What do you think? That would be the very definition of madness.
Come back and do a review when you get it, V V!
Only after listening to all of the discs the mandatory six times
Mods, you can free up that 15GB of space you had reserved for my extensive Bonzos Budget Busting Box review after all. For one thing, it wouldn’t be needed for about four years (viz. Jaygee’s reminder of the mandatory six listens) and for another, I came to my senses.
I have bought many CD box sets in the past but I always look for VFM alongside my desire for the artist’s music.
I don’t buy vinyl boxes. In fact I very rarely buy any vinyl at all. It would have to be something that’s unavailable in other formats and even then it would have to pass my VFM test.
My budget is limited and the more recorded music I buy, the less money I have for live music. Live low-cost gigs are my priority these days. Fortunately, there are enough of them occurring in my locality to be able to be choosy about which I go to.
I do buy CDs from artist’s merch tables, when funds allow. I’ve even been known to buy t-shirts.
I’d love it, but I already have Cornology and a couple of old LPs, so it won’t be for me at £250.
I’m intrigued to find put what they have found to put on 17 CDs! They only made 6 albums, and there is some BBC stuff, but where has this all come from?
My thought exactly – what on earth is on all these discs?
John Wayne and Adolf’s percussive duets, Val’s rocking chair squeaks and a load of Viv’s farting noises.
“Four years ago, I was six vinyl LPs. Today I am seventeen separate CDs.”
In the first 20 years if his career Neil Young released about 20 albums. Encompassing the same period he has now put out over 60 other albums in various formats, unreleased ones, live ones, alternate versions etc. And they are all great! *
* Well most of them
Better revise those figures, @Dai, he put out two more albums while you were typing that
Ha!
@Dai
The good news is he’s putting a toe in the water re playing
live again.
https://www.uncut.co.uk/news/watch-neil-young-play-1977s-hey-babe-live-for-the-first-time-147269/
Did you weaken and buy A3, D?
Bought the 2 LP Tracks collection which is pretty good
Glad he is out there again. I may have seen the last full length Crazy Horse concert 🙁
I haven’t picked up the physical set, but a friend helped me out 😉
Too heavy?
🙂
FWIW, AUK has the Archive 3 double vinyl sampler F#&@ Up double live vinyl for £15 each
https://superdeluxeedition.com/deal/box-set-and-reissue-deals-for-july-2025/
I really like the Bonzos at their best, but there is quite a lot of patchy stuff even on the 3CD Cornology. God knows what a 17 CD release would amount to.
https://dmme.net/classic-bonzo-dog-doo-dah-band-material-goes-into-a-box/?fbclid=IwY2xjawFmbONleHRuA2FlbQIxMQABHZKpynzk72ZqqF6m9LK4IZVfMZeXM0JPawituGK4KOUVxamwqYTnzq13fw_aem_tnOzRHrCKeNnbC1XXyjWjA
This should tell you all you need to gnaow.
A quick heads-up for anyone who fancied this but not at the high price, it’s on Amazon.de limited offer for 120 quid
https://superdeluxeedition.com/deal/box-set-and-reissue-deals-for-july-2025/#comments-211371