No official announcement as yet, but the jungle drums are beating louder it seems..
Comments
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.

Musings on the byways of popular culture
No official announcement as yet, but the jungle drums are beating louder it seems..
You must be logged in to post a comment.

Not their best. A bit forced, lyrically and conceptually.
Their second best, after The Final Cut.
One of their many best albums!
Wish you were Here
Dark Side of the Moon
Meddle
Piper at the Gates of Dawn
Saucerful of Secrets
The Division Bell
The Wall
Obscured by Clouds
Pulse
…Animals…
Where’s Atom Heart Mother?
Never really liked that- even though I appreciate its place in the development of the band and, of course, the brilliant cover. For me the ‘tunes’ didn’t really gel and (again purely just my opinion) it represented tha awkward period of a band still in transition and trying to find their feet after Syd. It took a while and I reckon it was ushered in on Meddle.
Final Cut
Animals
WYWH
DSOTM
The Wall
Meddle
So wrong.
If this is what we’re doing, I’ll put this down and wait for the opprobrium:
Meddle
Obscured by Clouds
Dark Side…
WYWH
Atom Heart Mother
Animals
More
Ummagumma
Saucerful
Piper
The remix transforms the original release. I don’t think it’s top 3 but still very good
Can hear the sound of the barrel being scraped
Sony control the catalogue now so presumably we can expect this for all the albums as they seek to recoup their investment.
It’s my favourite Floyd album. I think Dogs is the best thing they ever did.
My comparative rating would be:
Animals
DSOTM
WYWH (to be honest, nothing separating these two).
[daylight]
Meddle
[acres of blue sky]
The Wall
Obscured by Clouds/More (can’t really remember anything from either of them)
[galactic vistas]
The twee, juvenile shit they did with Syd Barrett.
Even wronger.
That ‘twee, juvenile shit’ can also, of course, be interpreted as being one of the most original and poetic evocation of the vision of childhood since the days of Wordsworth. It hadn’t been explored quite so effectively in popular song before this. Neither had the dark subject matter of ‘Arnold Layne’ and the R.D. Laing-infused themes of ‘See Emily Play’ (themes of perceived madness v perceived sanity which the band never really abandoned completely during their post -Syd years- most notably on Dark Side and WYWH). Additionally- and not insignificantly- Barrett’s plain ‘English’ delivery (as opposed to the ‘American’ norm of almost every other British singer of the period) was also hugely influential and can be heard in a thousand contemporary indie bands where, consciously or not, Syd’s outsider chic is celebrated as being a somewhat essential ingredient in the ‘rock star’ mystique. But yes. Some see it as twee and juvenile…
Perfectly put, @Eddieg.
Superb appreciation. Thanks @eddieg.
It’s a great album, but didn’t they only just release this new mix a few years ago (and again with an Atmos mix a couple of years ago). I can’t really see what could be different this time round with the mix (I assume the messrs Waters and Gilmour have definitely not talked and agreed on yet another mix)
2018 for the remix. Eight years ago.
But wasn’t it that whilst the remix was done in 2018 it was only released in 2022 (as they couldn’t agree ?)
Correct. They put out the 2018 remix in 2022, which included a 2018 5.1 surround mix, and then followed that up with a separate new Atmos remix in 2024 on bluray (which also included the 2018 and 1977 mixes). IIRC the Animals Atmos bluray was the last thing put out while Floyd still had control. The four year delay in getting the 2018 mixes out was because Dave vetoed the sleeve notes Roger wanted in the reissue.
Anyways, now that Sony own everything and Dave and Rog have no say, we can get a “proper” Animals box. So yes, it’s wild that this is the third Animals reissue in the 2020s, but this new release is what should have come out in the first place.
Can we allow ourselves to get excited about a possible 60th Piper At The Gates Of Dawn set?
The selling point really is the previously unreleased material, such as the early versions of Dogs and Sheep, plus the live show – although most of this has been around on the internet for a number of years to be fair.
Hope there’ll be a standalone bluray as they did for WYWH50, but as you say, this is the release that the original reissue should have been..
Note for the curious, Waters did subsequently publish Mark Blake’s missing sleeve notes on his website.
I think the problem has always been that Animals is kind of a twin album with Wish You Were Here, in that the bulk of the material comes from the same writing sessions (not all of it, and the theme was added on top of the existing songs). Given that the band had very little material that they didn’t use, it’s been probably hard to figure out what to release. I would imagine that the Oakland gig is from a bootleg source, although I would love to be proved wrong. There’s a pretty decent multi-source reconstructed version of that gig already out there on teh interwebs.
Odd that they appear not to have included the 8 track, joined up, version of Pigs on the Wing though…
I feel less bad about time galloping away now. Thank you
It’s a very paltry Blu-ray, the Wish You Were Here one has amazing content. Almost a box set on one disc, how it should be
There are also studio versions of You Gotta Be Crazy and Raving and Drooling (in their original form) that were on the Immersion version of Wish You Were Here, and available as ‘singles’ via streaming. I controversially reckon that Have a Cigar is the prototype of Pigs (Three Different Ones)…
Why is that controversial? They’re practically the same song!
Not to be too pedantic (!) but they were live versions from Wembley 1974, not studio recordings – they’ve never emerged and presumably don’t exist as they would either have appeared on WYWH50 or Animals50.
Ooops, yes. I’m getting confused, and probably dragged down by the stone.
They didn’t include this one, maybe too close to rhe finished version, no sound effects or talk box, different solo at the end.
Re: the Floyd,
To any Afterword Floyd fans who haven’t picked up the “Live from the Los Angeles Sports Arena, April 26th, 1975” set, which was released in April this year, I can highly recommend it.
Yes that’s a great set, and of course includes the prototypes of Dogs and Sheep.
The canny Floyd fan can find it on the Wish You Were Here bluray which as mentioned upthread, is a perfect box set in itself. And the Atmos WYWH mix is a banger
Officially announced now and as with WYWH50, the bluray is the one to go for as it includes all of the content from the full set.
Galling that they haven’t included the 8 track version of Pigs on the Wing, a glaring omission really that makes the set not quite comprehensive for the completist – can only think it’s because it was the selling point of the 8 tracks compilation earlier this year.
Released 22 January.
Looking ahead, I wonder what the next release will be – the 50th anniversary of The Wall isn’t until 30 November 2029, and I don’t see Sony letting almost 3 years pass after Animals 50 without releasing anything else.
Perhaps they’ll go back to the beginning with Piper60 etc…
The Wall Immersion Edition is still quite easy to find, and I suspect it didn’t sell as well as the others. It’s also the only one that has a significant amount of unreleased content from the studio, painting the sessions in a different light vs the often repeated tales. I think it’s the definitive word on the album. If Sony do anything, it will probably be more expensive and less good.
I don’t think they’ll pass up the opportunity somehow! Atmos mix for sure and reading James Guthrie’s notes in the Immersion set I think there’s a lot more outtakes still in the vault, although probably a case of more of the same. Then there’s the aborted film of the Earls Court 1981 shows that could potentially be resurrected with advances in technology.
If the Oakland gig was released as a standard 2CD set, I’d buy it, but I’m not shelling out for a deluxe box set, even though “Animals” is may favourite Floyd album.
Maybe they’ll put out the Oakland concert as a stand-alone Record Store Day release (as the 1975 Los Angeles gig was)?
I’d say that’s a safe bet.