The odd “serving” of Come Dine With Me or “stopover” at Four in a Bed (SWIDT?) aside, I normally can’t stomach reality shows and gave this a miss when it showed last month.
Having heard nothing but praise from friends whose televisual recommendations are normally pretty good, I gave it a go and a brilliant, hugely addictive show it is, too.
PLot basically involves 22 contestants in a Scottish castle joining forces to take on increasingly difficult challenges to try and earn themselves a share in a possible £120K jackpot.
The only fly in the ointment is that three of the competitors are “traitors” whose job it is to grab the loot for themselves by “murdering” the rest of the group (called “faithful”) one victim every night they’re in the castle. The faithfuls have their shot at identifying and getting rid of the traitors at nightly banishment sessions.
The amount of mind-fucking that goes on makes for must binge telly.
Give it a go, you’ll be hooked within the first episode.
Above describes the UK version. Not seen the celeb-driven US version yet but having devoured the UK one in three nights I defiintely will

Despite the near universal praise this show has received it’s my perception of the ‘amount of mind-fucking that goes on’ which puts me off. There’s enough suspicion and paranoia in my life already without seeking it out for leisure. I was even deeply uncomfortable in the episode of the last series of Taskmaster when the viewers knew that John Kearns was on a mission to sabotage the task without his team mates knowing.
The US version is completely bonkers and completely addictive!
I concur about the U.K. version. I don’t watch reality TV at all, stumbled on this and found myself addicted. The last 20 mins was the most compelling TV of last year! Seriously!
I have shared my “guilty pleasure” with family and friends who all lapped it up as well
No thanks.
Yeah. Nah.
Reality TV? I’d really love to, but I’m busy having a vasectomy done with a Victorian lawnmower.
Give the US version (iPlayer) a go for 10 mins …go on.
You can thank me later.
(Never lasted more than 27.3 seconds of a Reality Show before)
Well….
that changes everything Lodey. Your advice is invaluable to me.
(invaluable means the same as worthless, right?)
As ever I’ll see you at the bus stop at 8pm. (Last time I thought, to be honest, the Ostrich costume didn’t really suit you. Let’s hope it’s not raining. Ah, forgotten for a moment we live in Hull)
I can’t, I’m watching the telly. They’re repeating 321 on Challenge. It’s like Only Connect, but more highbrow.
Awful shite telly, I thought. My brother enthusiastically recommended it to me so I gave the first episode a go but couldn’t go any further.
I wrote a song a while back called Crying on Camera. The first verse goes:
Everybody, look at me
I want the world to see
I’ve got no dignity
I’m on reality TV
And I’m crying on camera
Watching this shite made got me playing that song again. So that’s nice.
For you, maybe.
And for humanity.
Which version UK or US (asking for a “friend”)?
I have no idea what “friend” means
He’s done two different versions of his “song”? The US one he leaves out the “Cor blimey”s and runs all the swears backwards, presumably?
UK
YUK
I can highly recommend it as great telly.
I have an aversion to anything to do with reality TV normally but this was excellent and totally binge worthy.
You are a man of great taste, Uncle ( see the Led Zep thread)
I have mentioned on here before that I am an avid boardgamer, and just heard this being discussed on a boardgaming podcast this morning. For this show, they’ve taken mechanisms from popular social deduction games, which usually involve a traitor/traitors of some sort. It’s a mechanism with lots of interesting variations, so hopefully the show builds on that.
That being said, I would never actually watch the show!
It’s good – especially on catch up. It hits the spot where our house can coincide on a programme (15 year old kids and mature adults). Surprisingly rare.
It does cliffhangers, twists and the journey thing well. Claudia Winkleman is also very good – although I am distracted by her fringe and the concern that she will need to move on from that hair style soon.
Anyone watching Series 2? Just finished ep 1 and it’s every bit as good as S1
Reality TV? Sorry, I’m too busy hammering rusty nails into my scrotum.
But you’re missing Claudia Winkleman. All orange and fringey.
I don’t watch it but it’s on when I’m reading the Afterword. I looked up to see Claudia’s fringe practically blown off her head. The sight fair frightened the horses.
What a rich, full life you must lead, Moosey…
A lot more nuanced than your bog standard Big Brother fare, M.
No fan of Realty TV myself, I had no great expectations of this,
but was well impressed by the level of head fuckery the format
allows..
Give it an hour, you might be pleasantly surprised.
If nothing else, your scrotum will be glad of the break.
I’ve seen nothing to refute my first impression above that the programme is based around the sort of mind games I would find excruciating to watch. I too would rather spend my time hammering rusty nails into
myMoose’s scrotum.Yes, but isn’t that true of everything, you sadistic monster?