This. utterly lame. Chris Spedding must be in triple scale to be involved in this dampest of squibs. I like BF but he can’t do covers. He can’t play the harmonica either.
I was just a kid when I heard it and had no idea who Dylan was. I loved it. Still do. I have since grown to love and revere His Bobness but…(whisper it)…I actually prefer Ferry’s version.
Ferry of course has since admitted that he based his bizarrely phrased early singing style (on things like Virginia Plain and the classic Roxy singles in particular) on Dylan’s approach. Almost a parody (Steve Harley adopted the same exaggerated style on those Cockney Rebel tunes) but, as we have since discovered (with regard to both singers) done out of pure respect.
Not trolling, I think it’s fey and weedy after the original. And I repeat I like BG but that arch, contrived singing style doesn’t suit covers, but does his own songs. OOAA. See also Bowie, D.
I did an episode of Albumtoalbum with Nick Pegg discussing Tonight – God Only Knows is one of the very few instances where Pegg conceded Bowie monumentally lost the plot.
His version of Jonathan Richman’s Pablo Picasso is nothing short of criminal. The only justification was that maybe he thought Jonathan could benefit from the royalties.
It might well have been the case – though I don’t mind that version of Pablo Picasso, His band are cooking on gas, especially Slick’s cod-flamenco guitar flourishes counterbalancing the slamming verses
And he has form when it comes to helping people out with cover versions – Iggy and the IRS got a few years blessed respite from each other post Let’s Dance/Tonight, for example
I’ve always liked his covers. I have no problem with LST, always liked AHRGF – and for many years considered his version of The In-Crowd to be the definitive version.
A bit obscure, but a number of years go I bought a double CD of Chris Farlowe’s Immediate recordings. Like a lot of those ‘complete recordings’ sets, there are many dog turds amongst the diamonds. The worst by far is his version of ‘Yesterday’ which is so utterly unsuitable for his vocal style.
I say thee nay! It trundles along in a neither-here-nor-there fashion, until 1:32 when that booming organ explodes onto the scene and turns it into a thing of beauty indeed….those who read Uncut may recall it appearing among others on the “Why Don’t We Do It In The Road” free CD of Beatles covers that came with it back in 2001 (there was also a pretty good Joe Cocker cover of “I’ll Cry Instead” and a topsa cover of [of all things] “Within You Without You” by Rainer Ptacek)
There was also ones for the White album (which I have) and one for Revolver, which I saw in a Cromer charity shop on Saturday. When I saw the £4 sticker, I put it back on the shelf. I expect it will still be there when I go back next Easter.
If you didn’t want to slap the members of Sixpence None The Richer because of their name, have a listen to this beige emasculation of the La’s classic. All the yearning and passion of the original is gone, rinsed out and replaced with anodyne, grinning tweeness.
The Blue `Nile are, pretty much, uncoverable* in my opinion. The Downtown Lights seems to be the song that people are most disposed to ‘having a go” at.
Annie Lennox basically copies the Blue Nile arrangement but sprays audio Dettol over the whole thing and makes it the coldest, lifeless thing ever.
Rod Stewart decides to fully Kenny G the shit out of the song, proving that anything Annie Lennox can do, ge can do it better.
* There is a live studio version by Keane which is actually alright.
“Annie Lennox basically copies the Blue Nile arrangement but sprays audio Dettol over the whole thing and makes it the coldest, (most) lifeless thing ever.”
Basically sums up how I feel about Annie Lennox in general…
Oh yes, and I was the lucky Massive-er who witnessed it in all its live, er, glory.
It was a jukebox musical called The Spirit Of Rock’n’Roll, and also ‘starred’ Mike Holoway, who must have wondered what he had done to deserve this slow career death after his imperial years as a Look-In staple and teen heart-throb with the mighty Flintlock.
Won’t post a link – thank me later – but my personal, ahem, “favourite” is The Hollies doing “Blowin’ In The Wind” on their “Hollies Sing Dylan” album.
Starts off ok – Allan Clarke singing the first verse slowly against a fairly spartan backdrop – but, once he’s finished that, they leap into a horribly ill-advised Rat Pack crooner take on the song that’s so profoundly inappropriate to it that it verges on a deliberate parody.
I hate the Rat Pack anyway… and Allan Clarke vamping away trying to be Sinatra on a Dylan protest song (“Blow-ow-ow-ow-owin’ in the wind” etc etc) is not for the faint-hearted.
Reader, I am the faint-hearted. and I can happily live without ever hearing THAT again.
Actually the Doors thread reminds me that Jose Feliciano did a toe curling version of Light My Fire which was popular in the 70s. My parents might have had the album. At any rate I loathed it.
Phil Collins has often complained about Paul McCartney’s slights and snubs in the past but having heard Phil’s version of Tomorrow Never Knows, you can understand why.
The Stones, Like A Rolling Stone. First encountered on Still Life, but pick a performance, any of them, they’re all awful. Mick has no idea how to sing that song.
Dreadfully dull group all round for me I’m afraid.
I rather enjoy this one: “My woman keeps me warm!”
Actually that’s quite impressive I don’t like Baker Street and they’ve managed to make it sound even worse.
I like it a lot, but it’s about time Gerry Rafferty did some new material 🙄
Looks like they got Animal from the Muppets to replace Taylor Hawkins on drums
I love Frank Skinner’s line about Baker Street. The sax solo sounding like Sweep “waxing lyrical”.
Any song ever used by John Lewis (and others) in an advert, particularly for Christmas.
This. utterly lame. Chris Spedding must be in triple scale to be involved in this dampest of squibs. I like BF but he can’t do covers. He can’t play the harmonica either.
Oooh. Contentious or just trolling? You are the ref.
Contentious indeed! I do love this version – if you want a dismal cover of LST, check out Dylan’s from Down In The Groove.
Meanwhile, Bryan often gave good cover – there’s this, The In Crowd, The Price of Love, Jealous Guy, Hard Rain’s Gonna Fall, etc
I thought BF’s Hard Rain was awful when I first heard it however after all these years I haven’t changed my mind.
I was just a kid when I heard it and had no idea who Dylan was. I loved it. Still do. I have since grown to love and revere His Bobness but…(whisper it)…I actually prefer Ferry’s version.
That’s possibly it I was an ‘adult’ when it came out.
Does what a good cover should want to achieve, sounds like a completely different song
I don’t dislike cover songs that make them sound like different songs.
But I still don’t like the sound of that one.
Fair enough, I think it’s a total banger
Same. I love the way that, apart from the solo, the sax players only play one note through the entire song.
I think it’s dreadful.
Ferry of course has since admitted that he based his bizarrely phrased early singing style (on things like Virginia Plain and the classic Roxy singles in particular) on Dylan’s approach. Almost a parody (Steve Harley adopted the same exaggerated style on those Cockney Rebel tunes) but, as we have since discovered (with regard to both singers) done out of pure respect.
Yes I can hear that.
Not trolling, I think it’s fey and weedy after the original. And I repeat I like BG but that arch, contrived singing style doesn’t suit covers, but does his own songs. OOAA. See also Bowie, D.
Bowie has loads of great covers but a few very bad ones too
I did an episode of Albumtoalbum with Nick Pegg discussing Tonight – God Only Knows is one of the very few instances where Pegg conceded Bowie monumentally lost the plot.
His version of Jonathan Richman’s Pablo Picasso is nothing short of criminal. The only justification was that maybe he thought Jonathan could benefit from the royalties.
I quite liked his version of ‘Cactus’…
Improves on the original. Altogether now – “D. A. V. I. D!”
It might well have been the case – though I don’t mind that version of Pablo Picasso, His band are cooking on gas, especially Slick’s cod-flamenco guitar flourishes counterbalancing the slamming verses
And he has form when it comes to helping people out with cover versions – Iggy and the IRS got a few years blessed respite from each other post Let’s Dance/Tonight, for example
Great record! The big question is around Jerry Hall’s vocal contribution. Love the strutting but does she make those noises?
You’d have to ask Mick…(where is that confounded Moose?)
Definitive version!
Wor Bryan is the consummate cover artist. Half of his solo oeuvre is what he calls ‘readymades’.
I’ve always liked his covers. I have no problem with LST, always liked AHRGF – and for many years considered his version of The In-Crowd to be the definitive version.
Not convinced by this choice of cover
Duran Duran famously covered Public Enemy’s “911 is a Joke” as well…
I quite like good covers album, but the Duran Duran album has very little to redeem it
I always thought this was a bizarre cover; giving a 60s psychedelic classic a 90s handbag house makeover:
A bit obscure, but a number of years go I bought a double CD of Chris Farlowe’s Immediate recordings. Like a lot of those ‘complete recordings’ sets, there are many dog turds amongst the diamonds. The worst by far is his version of ‘Yesterday’ which is so utterly unsuitable for his vocal style.
Don’t listen, I beg you….
I say thee nay! It trundles along in a neither-here-nor-there fashion, until 1:32 when that booming organ explodes onto the scene and turns it into a thing of beauty indeed….those who read Uncut may recall it appearing among others on the “Why Don’t We Do It In The Road” free CD of Beatles covers that came with it back in 2001 (there was also a pretty good Joe Cocker cover of “I’ll Cry Instead” and a topsa cover of [of all things] “Within You Without You” by Rainer Ptacek)
Wasn’t there also a Mojo free CD featuring covers of Abbey Road? Possibly around 2009?
https://www.discogs.com/release/1955105-Various-Abbey-Road-Now-Mojo-Presents-The-Beatles-1969-Classic-Re-Recorded
October
There was also ones for the White album (which I have) and one for Revolver, which I saw in a Cromer charity shop on Saturday. When I saw the £4 sticker, I put it back on the shelf. I expect it will still be there when I go back next Easter.
https://www.discogs.com/release/740231-Various-Revolver-Reloaded-Mojo-Presents-Their-1966-Masterpiece-Covered-In-Full
I had a good Mojo covers of The River. Thea Gilmore did a good take on “Cover Me”.
Two bands I love have done two of the worst covers I know…
The Undertones – Under the Boardwalk and Altered Images – Song Sung Blue.
Wretched.
If you didn’t want to slap the members of Sixpence None The Richer because of their name, have a listen to this beige emasculation of the La’s classic. All the yearning and passion of the original is gone, rinsed out and replaced with anodyne, grinning tweeness.
Jeez, that’s absolutely awful. I’ve heard buskers do it better.
I’m going to track down a copy now and play it in my “I can’t believe it’s not better” radio slot.
I won’t provide a link as I am not that cruel, but Oasis doing My Generation is absolutely dreadful.
Oasis doing most things (Walrus, Heroes, etc) is reliably dire
Oh yes, I had removed their version of Heroes from my mind. That was horrendous
The Blue `Nile are, pretty much, uncoverable* in my opinion. The Downtown Lights seems to be the song that people are most disposed to ‘having a go” at.
Annie Lennox basically copies the Blue Nile arrangement but sprays audio Dettol over the whole thing and makes it the coldest, lifeless thing ever.
Rod Stewart decides to fully Kenny G the shit out of the song, proving that anything Annie Lennox can do, ge can do it better.
* There is a live studio version by Keane which is actually alright.
“Annie Lennox basically copies the Blue Nile arrangement but sprays audio Dettol over the whole thing and makes it the coldest, (most) lifeless thing ever.”
Basically sums up how I feel about Annie Lennox in general…
Rab Noakes does a lovely (in my opinion) version of it.
He really does.
I read the title and was initially surprised to learn that the bloke from Blue Peter had brought out a record at some point.
Terrible cover version, you say? Surely THIS is the gold…..er, brown standard:
Wasn’t that performed in character as a part he was portraying at the time?
Oh yes, and I was the lucky Massive-er who witnessed it in all its live, er, glory.
It was a jukebox musical called The Spirit Of Rock’n’Roll, and also ‘starred’ Mike Holoway, who must have wondered what he had done to deserve this slow career death after his imperial years as a Look-In staple and teen heart-throb with the mighty Flintlock.
Perhaps it was karma for their atrocious cover of Rocky Mountain Way.
Here’s Gary Numan and Leo Sayer singing On Broadway. You’re welcome.
Won’t post a link – thank me later – but my personal, ahem, “favourite” is The Hollies doing “Blowin’ In The Wind” on their “Hollies Sing Dylan” album.
Starts off ok – Allan Clarke singing the first verse slowly against a fairly spartan backdrop – but, once he’s finished that, they leap into a horribly ill-advised Rat Pack crooner take on the song that’s so profoundly inappropriate to it that it verges on a deliberate parody.
I hate the Rat Pack anyway… and Allan Clarke vamping away trying to be Sinatra on a Dylan protest song (“Blow-ow-ow-ow-owin’ in the wind” etc etc) is not for the faint-hearted.
Reader, I am the faint-hearted. and I can happily live without ever hearing THAT again.
Actually the Doors thread reminds me that Jose Feliciano did a toe curling version of Light My Fire which was popular in the 70s. My parents might have had the album. At any rate I loathed it.
Oof! I think my parents had that as well, his rapid repetition of “light my fire” always irritated me.
That’s the one. Whilst gurning.
A toe-curling version of “Light My Fire”?
Surely it can’t be worse than Massive Attack’s version of the very same Doors tune?
You want the worst cover ever…
From the Gene Simmons solo album that has songs co-written with Bob Dylan.
That is terrible in every way.
Curiosity got the better of me and I clicked on it. I lasted 10-15 seconds. Horrendous.
Yikesamundo!!
Correct. Ye gods….
Phil Collins has often complained about Paul McCartney’s slights and snubs in the past but having heard Phil’s version of Tomorrow Never Knows, you can understand why.
The Stones, Like A Rolling Stone. First encountered on Still Life, but pick a performance, any of them, they’re all awful. Mick has no idea how to sing that song.
Not on Still Life, more a mid 90s thing
And I loved the juxtaposition of them leaping on the unrelated song.