Yes I like AJ too. I also like William Rees Mogg but mainly because he is such a wind up merchant and I can perfectly see why many can’t stand him. I think he’s hilarious.
God I’m having a mare with this. I meant JACOB. Engage brain before posting. It was great watching that pompous ass Evan Davis barraging him with evidence from experts and JRM rendering him speechless by saying “these people are little more that star gazers and soothsayers”.
It’s nice to see Ken Clarke still in rude health, about 30 years after Alan Clark referred to him as “a walking life insurance risk” in his diaries. Ha!
Back in the 90s during my sell-my-soul-to-the-devil-corporate-gigging days in a London hotel, my band was asked to turn down by Ken Clarke (Actually he sent some hotel staff flunky to ask for him). We did NOT turn down (he wasn’t the paying client). I remember inwardly punching the air and exclaiming to myself “YESS… too loud for the Tories”
I am a fan of Hillary Benn too. When he went up against Osborne in PMQs last year he was a breath of fresh air & did exactly what an opposition MP should do i.e. ask pertinent questions & call them out when they avoid answering. Something that Jeremy Corbyn is woeful at IMHO.
Have you watched PMQ’s recently? Corbyn is doing an excellent job exposing May, particularly on the NHS. She never answers a question, preferring to rely on pre-prepared insults and blaming the last Labour Government for everything, despite her being a member of the government for the last 7 years.
It’s true, he has got better at reading out prepared questions, but it’s taken 18 months so nothing to be proud of really. The Surrey CC leaks were a gift, nothing to do with his leadership.
I’m an ABC but lost a lot of respect for Hilary Benn when he triggered a totally pointless and self-destructive leadership campaign against Corbyn then did not stand himself.
Mbeppe looks a player, but we knew that, he’ll go for a packet. Bernardo Silva has been the surprise – only 22, didn’t realise he was this good.
I’d be happy enough if I was a city fan – this has been a great game of football, and it’s not over yet. The desire to cut Guardiola down to size is so very, very English.
Oh come now @dodger-lane, Bundesliga’s less moneyed but a decent league. Pep made it impossible to hate Bayern for the three years he was there, such was his cultured approach to football and life. Now he’s gone, normality has been resumed.
We’ve done this before @Bingo-Little and my comment was tongue in cheek. Monaco are still a great team and Pep is obviously a great manager. Football is all opinions as last nights game proved. Best game of football I’ve seen in a long time. Let’s pick this conversation up again at the end of the season.
I’m not Guardiola’s mum, and I’m not going to endlessly defend him against all criticism. He’s quite obviously a very very good manager, and he put together the best football team I’ve ever seen. His teams always play on the front foot and I enjoy watching them. That’s about it.
If you want an angle to criticise him for last night you might note that he had his arse saved by a centre forward who, until now, he’s been slowly working out of the club. Beyond that, just happy to watch a really, really good game of football between two sides who just went at each other all night.
@bingo-little@dave-amitri as a City fan, certainly the most thrilling game since the Agueeerrrrooooo title winner. Not for one of a nervous disposition, as good though Monaco were (buy Silva to start to replace Silva is an obvs move) Stones and Otamendi were uncomfortable all night. Having a back 3 meant a huge space on the opposite side to where the ball was as the defence shuffled across, which Monaco exploited for the first hour. Can’t believe that CB partnership will start next year. Yes Serge was a leader – even tackling back just outside our penalty area. I think a lot of the Pep easing people out stuff is smoke and mirrors – look at Yaya earlier on in this season, though he was about our most anonymous player yesterday. We are some strange football version of the human centipede at the moment: a forward/MF line that looks irresistible – how good is Sane starting to look – joined to a defence that frequently looks terrified, with neither punting it look or playing out from the back working too well.
Thought David Silva was electric in the closing stages, really rolled back the years, and that trio of Sane, Sterling and De Bruyne is superb and will only improve.
Aguero – I said to some mates back in September that I wondered if it would work out for him under Pep – pressing and tracking back aren’t his forte, and that’s what guardiola tends to look for. Last night was the first time this season that I’ve seen Aguero properly adapt his game, and that tackle you mention was an eyebrow raising moment. I harbour a secret hope that we might swap you Sanchez for Aguero, because I think the latter remains the best player in the country.
Can’t speak for Otamendi, but I’ve seen Stones play several times in the flesh, for both yourselves and Everton, and if he’s a centre back I’m a monkey’s uncle. Lovely on the ball, but absolutely no sense of danger (the two may be linked). I suspect you’ll be watching Virgil Van Dijk next season.
Yes the only match we’ve seen live this season was the home match v Soton – went behind to a Stones error. VVD was immense (in all senses of the word). Hope we do get him, though we’ll probably sign 3 more ‘pacy mids’ as my son says instead. Surely even Pep can see something is wrong if he ends up playing Fernandinho at RB.
Re Silva – my son has also never seen a ‘slide-rule’ so beloved of commentators. Can we think of a new metaphor – perhaps that pass was ‘precison laser-guided’
Can’t work out if the Churchill nomination was serious and can’t see it is was vetoed as Man City seemed to take over. But, just in case, I veto Churchill.
I did politics A level and my class was being shown around the HOC about 30 years ago by the (now disgraced ex-jailbird) Barnsley MP, Eric Ilsley, when we walked past Skinner in the lobby. He spotted Ilsley and the conversation went “eyup Eric” – “eyup Dennis”. Made me chuckle. Very much doubt a meeting of two Tories bringing up similar greetings.
Apart from one or two from above, I also like Matthew Parris and Sarah Teather, but my favourite was Julian Critchley. Used to love reading anything he wrote.
I was at school with Son of Critchley, which obviously meant he came to school to talk to us.
Funny man, and I thought, quite smart. He had an interesting perspective on the idea that (at the time) the British press were superior to the US counterparts. It was, opined, rubbish, and he proceeded to demonstrate as such.
Interestingly, I think his “pair” at the HoC was The Beast of Bolsover
I don’t like Skinner at all. Professional northerner and self-caricature. His yawnsome set-yer-watch-by-him schoolboy antics at formal occasions might endear him to some but they just get on my tits.
I am a fan of his but do agree with the self-caricature comment. Unfortunately he has let his outspokenness become his calling card & it has got very tiresome. A pity as it the passion he displays which is lacking from a lot of MPs at the moment.
He’s allegedly a terribly human being but Nicky Soames gives very good twitter and I have found myself warming to him.
In a serious way as well, I’d like to nominate Rory Stewart. When he does Question Time he’s always the sensible guy speaking. A brilliant writer as well. It’s hard to believe he’s a tory.
RS has done a few good docs for the Beeb too. I don’t have this tribal thing that Tory = bastard / Labour = lovely caring person. There are both in both camps.
RS has written a couple of very good books about his time in Iraq and Afghanistan and I think he still is involved in charitable work in Afghanistan. I tend to admire this kind of politician who has had some real life experiences and then goes into politics.
Rory Stewart often seems like the token grown-up in the room (“Wait… this guy actually knows what he’s talking about! Geddimouttahere!”). And yes, his programme on the Borders was quite interesting and original.
– Alan Johnson. Reading This Boy is extraordinary, plus he has a sense of humour and seems to like his music.
– Ken Clarke. Thoughtful conservatism.
– George Osborn. I know, I know. He’s a millionaire, part of that awful set and his p.r is dreadful. But I have heard from people who know him what a very nice man he is, genuine and this is from Labour people. I think Teresa May made a huge mistake kicking him out and I credit him for staying in politics post Brexit.
– Matthew Parris. I wish he had stayed in politics.
I find it hard to admire anyone in the current Labour ranks, Corbyn may be a nice man but he’s hopeless and between him and his acolytes he’s going to ruin Labour not only as decent opposition for the next 4 years but as a serious alternative govt.
From the past, I liked and admired Michael Foot, treated shamefully by his own party and the media but a principled and witty speaker.
I’m sure about the same proportion as in any other walk of life are pleasant people. However I think almost all of the rest of them know how to charm.
It’s part of the training they get and an important part of how they persuade people to vote for them come election time, so being pleasant when chatting is not always a guide to true character.
There are some, of course, who cannot muster any charm at all, ever. Even if they try, which a few seemingly do not.
Alan Johnson was a shite short tem minister of health, so, that and his hair rules him out. As a paradox, Ken Clark, who was a major level cunt as minister of health I admire. Just as a consummate professional politician who has also (his) principles, and could turn his hand to any portfolio, and did.
My favourite was Frank Dobson. Good dude.
I work with MPs and generally find I like them, even the ones I don’t agree with. It’s much harder to hate people once you’ve actually met them. I can think of two though who I thought were really unpleasant, one who was spectacularly thick, lazy and xenophobic (and as such a perfect representative of his constituency) and one who seemed a little bit satanic. One of them’s a Minister now.
Steve Rotherham bought me a sandwich once, so he’s okay in my book. Tuna, it was.
Always remember a mate of mine who was a senior trade union official being completely won over by Cecil Parkinson who he reckoned was a top bloke. Of MPs I’ve met, Andy Burnham always seemed to me to be a good guy and in it for the right reasons. Keith Vaz, not so much.
Didn’t someone say on here ages ago that they met Thatcher and was fully prepared to spit in her face but was completely charmed when she talked to him.
Steve Rotherham came across as the type of MP we need on that fly on the wall documentary a year or so back. Seemed a very decent sort. The show also helped fill the void created by the death of Brian Sewell, by giving me Jacob Rees-Mogg to take the role of the person most likely to make me put my foot through the telly.
Agree about Clarke and Johnson. Of the younger intake Stella Creasey seems like a decent human being. And I know this will be unpopular but I’ve always liked Harriet Harman.
And what about Fiona Davidson – surely everyone’s favourite Tory?
And were he still alive I reckon everyone would go for Charles Kennedy – that was such a sad loss.
Stella Creasy … isn’t she, like, a world authority on top Yorkshire indie band and Peel favourites The Wedding Present? I think she’s written sleeve notes for one of their albums or something.
Soft spot for Ken Clarke, David Penhaligon, Frank Field, Alan Johnson, Kate Hoey and Gisela Stewart. I’ve met and worked with one or two over the years. Nice ones included Wayne David (whose brother taught me maths), Tristan Garel-Jones, Hilary Benn and, er, Leon Brittan. Tony Benn seemed decent if flawed – banning pirate radio, going out of his way to dodge inheritance tax and advocating ruinous policies from a position of vast wealth.
Is the Field/Hoey/Stewart thing because of Brexit?
I don’t know much about Gisela Stewart apart from that, but Kate Hoey is awful. If you look at her issue profile the only reason she never stood as UKIP or Tory can only be that in her constituency, they’re only ever going to elect someone on a Labour ticket. I don’t mind people having a different set of views to me but that strikes me as wildly cynical.
God no. I didn’t know FF was pro-Brexit. He – along with IDS (come friendly bombs) is one of the few politicians who’s thought carefully and outside the box on welfare reform, a huge issue in parts of the country like my home town, that both Thatcher and Blair ducked. He manages to rise above the yah-boo nonsense to support things that actually have a chance of improving people’s lives, rather than patronising them and encouraging defeatism. GS always impressive on This Week. Hoey – like most politicians I admire – seems more enamoured of her principles than party line or career.
IDS spent time thinking outside the box – maybe. What he certainly did at the DWP is spend most of his time making life as difficult as possible for the poorest in the nation while living in a free house on his father-in-law’s estate, and lying through his teeth to Parliament. A truly loathsome individual.
Ha! Yes, I suspect we won’t agree Count. It always amazes me that lefties genuinely imagine that their political opponents either don’t care about people or are actively evil. Somewhat adolescent don’t you think?
I don’t agree with that. The people I know who are on “the right” are there because they believe (rightly or wrongly) in self determination over government assistance. They believe that the nanny state approach disempowers people and thrusts them into victimhood. They also believe that if we focus on making our society as a whole richer, the benefits will be felt by everyone.
I don’t agree with all of that, but I’ve certainly not found many people on the right who care about money more than people. They just have a different view of how best to help people.
I ran a quarter of the London Marathon with Mathew Parris MP but he left me for dead and finished in just over 2:30. He came over and congratulated me when I finished 20 minutes later.
Not a Tory fan but always thought he was a genuinely nice guy & a Hell of a runner.
Norman Lamb. He put money up for his son to start a record label for Grime. Where would Tynchie Stryder or Lethal Bizzle be without him? He also talks good sense on health matters.
I’m warming to David Lammy. He’s stuck to his guns during the Article 50 shitshow.
Not that this has anything to do with anything, but he can really sing too. Some years ago, through a combination of circs to involved to go into, I found myself in a choir backing him when he sang Something Inside So Strong. He aced it.
I used to like her but she’s succumbed to generalised project fear lingo. It’s all going to hell in a hand basket, no one voted for this blah blah. I have very mixed and conflicting views on brexit but evidence of a bit of thought rather than headline spouting is what we need at the moment. See also Farron, T.
Oh yes indeedy. Philip Davies is an absolutely wretched person, though he answers his mail which apparently endears him to many of our fellow constituents despite his fondness for filibustering free hospital car parking for carers, a domestic violence bill, and his overt sexism which he portrays as being pro-men (his approach is that men should be dragged down to suffer with the women rather than women raised up to be equal to men).
Talking to Shipley Feminist Zealots on Saturday if you fancy it.
Nope, vetoed. What some people like about him – his telly persona – sticks in my craw. I am shallow, but his ridiculous dress sense and the way he cradles his Bradshaws makes him unwatchable. Also he remains in favour of the disastrous way in which BR was privatised.
A former Tory defence secretary – deeply Thatcherite – who goes on telly and says that renewing Trident is a rotten idea and a criminal waste of money: whatever you think of him, a real Through-The-Looking-Glass moment.
Peter Kyle in Hove is a thoroughly good bloke who won the seat from the Tories in 2015. It’s one of only three Labour constituencies south of London and the only gain from the Conservatives. So of course the Corbynists in the local Labour party are trying to get rid of him, so they can lose it again next time.
I like Sarah Champion a lot. Plus Stella Creasy and Jess Phillips. I think in the case of the latter two if you’re getting non-stop crap from SWP misogynists you’re probably doing something right.
Abbott is my MP and I get the strong impression increasing numbers of previously Labour voters will be joining the fuck off queue come the next election.
I’m going to take this off in a different direction for a minute. Wouldn’t it be great if we could pick the best from all sides to form a government regardless of which party they represented? It seems to me to be really self harming to have good MP’s as backbenchers just because their party is unelectable. @Chiz made a comment on another thread about the fulcrum in politics and opinion which struck a real chord with me. Maybe we can get Ken Clarke and Co to start The Fulcrum Party and take the best of all parties, it would be like a political Band Aid. (Bad analogy)
No, it really wouldn’t. you need some underlying principles to tie a government together as it affects many many day to day decisions that we never see. For example – in favour of the NHS or not?
MPs are much less aligned to parties than people think. Most of their work is done in cross party committees and APPGs. It’s only the shouty show-off stuff in the Chamber where they have that whipped loyalty to their leadership. Elsewhere they’ll speak for their constituents and from their own experience. Select committees, which hold government agencies to account, are rarely tribal.
I’ll join the Fulcrum party! Although I suspect we may already have it, in the Lib Dems, and no one likes them very much at the moment.
Ha! Let’s do it. The Lib Dems knacker themselves because they won’t admit that the other parties might have a good idea, at least not publicly. The Fulcrum Party would accept that in order to find the true middle ground you have to accept left, right and centre, sometimes….. The Fulcrum Party – “Making Britain Balanced Again” (ok that needs some work…)
I’m a Lib Dem. I don’t think much of Tim Farron but they’re preferable to the others and at heart I’m a liberal. I have a pile of leaflets in the hall to junk mail to the locale later. I think you’d find that in many repeats they do have elements of the other parties but Farron is hardly going to credit either party with anything after the kicking they got for ensuring stable government in the Coalition. Sure they made mistakes, but the alternative would have been tremendous uncertainty at the worst possible time. Sadly our electorate is too immature to understand this.
You say that about the electorate but as we have seen recently if you can truly master the delivery of the message anything is possible. Cleggs meteoric rise proved that he got to the electorate, immature or otherwise, because he understood who he was talking too and how he needed to come across although I suspect it was entirely natural. No one will ever listen to Farron. I happen to think Theresa May understands that and has viewed what has happened over the lsat few years, realises the power is with the electorate and she needs to engage as many as possible. Something Corbyn is entirely clueless about
I agree with all that. By immaturity I mean the reflex hatred of the LDs because they “propped up” the Tories where in fact they drove them spare by muting the more swingeing aspects of what they wanted to do – as evidenced by the amount of complaining the Tories did about them. We appear to be unable to accept that working together isn’t automatically evidence of betrayal of principle. Compromise and finding common ground is what grown ups do.
Total Agreement. Sadly. They went wrong gambling nearly everything on PR voting (when a few minutes of calm thought would have shown Clegg et al that they were being stitched up).
Well, that’s me, you and Chiz. Are you with us @Twang How do you go about registering a political party and what’s our colour going to be? Rainbow has been taken, how about magnolia?
I think the LDs are the third way and I’m already signed up. You can chose the picture on your membership card. Mine has a pair of crossed legs wearing socks and sandles.
It’ll be interesting to see where their position on Europe gets them though – I’m not so sure all the noise about second referendum etc is going to translate to seats.
I think we are actually there – except the coalitions are within the parties. Not sure about the LDs, but there are at least 2 Labour parties slugging it out in the PLP and country, and 2 Tory parties doing the same less publicly. Realistically both of the could/should/would split if it did no mean electoral wilderness – and I’m not convinced they wont.
Well there’s a theory that the centre left from Labour and the centre Right from the Tories should form a new party leaving the hard left/right lot to their own devices.
I’m prompted to add that the single politician i found myself agreeing with the most, in government and out, was the late Robin Cook. Not universally popular, due to his irritating habit of being right.
His autobiography was an unexpectedly cracking read. I was expecting deeply thoughtful political musings but it’s actually quite easy and breezy. Very funny in parts too – he has a story where Tony Blair has a meeting with him in the Downing Street garden on a sunny day – as they walk around, Blair keeps moving them towards the sunshine, Cook keeps steering them back towards the shadows as Cook was prone to instant sunburn. The meeting was about something important but this subtle, unspoken power play between them was the main thing he remembered.
Doh ! Slaps forehead, of course. I went to hear CM promote one of his books, very witty and actually answered awkward questions. Plus his thrillers are great reads.
Yes, I always liked Chris Mullin. His book ‘View from the Foothills’ about the absurdities of being a junior minister in the Blair years is a great read.
Yes, as is the sequel. His take on Blair and Brown is interesting. He clearly loved Blair but thinks he got his one big thing (Iraq) horribly wrong, whereas he loathed Brown but credits him with getting his one big thing (averting global economic meltdown) right.
One thing’s for certain – that by-election is the biggest thing to hit Copeland since Morrissey unexpectedly played Whitehaven Civic Hall on his 2006 UK tour.
I lived in Workington then & couldnt get a ticket, it sold out virtually instantly & by all accounts it was brilliant.
Whitehaven civic was also where I saw the worst gig I ever went to.
Spiritualized – ladies & gentlemen, we are floating in space.
Or as the people of West Cumbria renamed it “Ladies & gentlemen we are leaving in droves” – Maybe I caught them on a bad night, but trust me, they were fucking dreadful.
Politicians? – I always liked James Callaghan & Dennis Healey.
Callaghan seemed to me like a bumbler who failed completely to keep it together as PM.
Healey was a devious, adaptable and extremely clever cove who probably would have done well in Michael Foot’s place.
Unfortunately he was seen as too tricky by the party hierarchy. They didn’t trust him to protect their interests, so they made sure he lost out to Foot.
I wonder whether the Tories might squeak Stoke – clearly pro hard-Brexit, but without the Nuttall element. The subject of Corbyn is poison on the doorstep at this point, I would’ve thought.
@friar they are nowhere in Stoke, neck and neck UKIP and Labour for the seat. They’re part of a coalition controlling the council with UKIP and independents.
Ah I wasn’t aware. Just going on the basis of how much of a kicking Nuttall has been taking lately, I thought perhaps the UKIP support might switch to another pro-Brexit party.
Just finished Gyles Brandreth’s book, ‘Breaking The Code’, about his time as an MP and Whip between 1992 and 1997. Whatever you may think about the Brandreth, it’s a fascinating read and full of wonderful gossip and anecdotes. Pretty much confirms the general view of Ken Clarke but waspish about Harriet Harman and a whole lot of lesser Tory and Labour MPs.
Question I’ve been wondering about for a while – if there was a General Election tomorrow, who would you vote for?
Not “is there a party you like” or “none of the above”: actual, for reals General Election at what looks like a critical moment in British history. Who do you vote for?
Surely the Greens don’t want to renew Trident.
I’d vote Labour. But you guessed that. Though I might be tempted by the “Anybody but Philip Davies please” party.
I’ve worked in a job where I was often in Parliament and rubbed shoulders with a few MPs, and have to say that most are very likeable face-to-face. I’ve got a theory that many become disagreeable twats when they appear on TV/radio and have to press their party line.
That being said, even when he was doing his party duty on the box I always liked our former MP Simon Hughes, and have a lot of time for Alan Johnson.
Don’t agree at all with choice of Corbyn; think he shows an appalling combination of ignorance and arrogance.
Non sycophant addressing Corbyn is called harassment in his brave new world. And he should know given his oay days from the Russian and Iranian state media.
I may be a little off-beam here, but didn’t Simon Hughes get elected by running a pretty vicious campaign against Peter Tatchell, highlighting the latter’s homosexuality in a traditional working class community. I remember it being very nasty and then a few years later Simon Hughes came out as gay when it was o.k to do so.
Most of the homophobic poison in that byelection was put out by other sections of the Labour party getting behind a guy they claimed was a ‘Real Labour’ candidate. If Hughes was guilty of anything at the time it was not speaking out against it.
His LibDems colleagues in the area have not always behaved honourably; but he’s not the only decent MP who has found himself with some scuzzy colleagues at constituency level.
I think that’s a revisionist view of how the Lib Dems behaved in that byelection. The idea that they were the entirely innocent and bewildered recipients of a homophobic vote is risible.
That was my experience from living next door to the constituency at the time. Maybe the LibDems were making some dodgy comments on the doorstep, but it was the ‘Real Labour’ crowd who were were being loudly homophobic.
Mhairi Black really impresses me. Every time I have heard her speak I have felt that she covers all angles of what she is saying & does so in a very measured way. She also has pointed out some of the hypocrisy of certain policies which I find very refreshing.
I do have a bit of an issue with someone as young as her being an MP. Only because I wonder how much a lack of life experience would impact on her beliefs. (i.e. not having a career prior to becoming an MP / buying a house / travelling etc.) I know that sounds particularly patronising but it is not meant to be.
I have had some correspondence with Jake Berry a Conservative MP in Lancashire. He is definitely a bell end of the highest order. His actions do not match how he votes, he likes to come across as very caring etc. but will then vote for policies that will impact his constituents negatively.
My local Conservative MP, Richard Harrington, is from the same mould as Berry by the sound of it.
He works hard on constituency business etc. and comes across as caring and pleasant and so on but never goes against the party whips or voices dissent when it comes to voting in the house. Likes to attach himself to local issues whether invited to or not. Especially if there’s some press in the offing.
Was against Brexit but did not exert himself particularly in support of his view. Probably because he knew local opinion was marginally Pro-Brexit.
Michael Fabricant, Micky Fab to his yaysayers, Flabbycunt to his naysayers, is my MP. Disagree bigtime with him on BREXIT, he being so excessively pro-exit as to resign his tory whip on principle when it was first aired by Callmedave, which at least displays principle. but he is otherwise a decent if eccentric dude who genuinely puts Lichfield first, forever bigging up local hospitals and curry houses in Parliament. Plus he is always a visible presence in the city, whether shopping or just being out and about. One of the few tories whose share of the vote kept on rising during the New Labour experiment. Of course I have never voted for him, but I have been tempted.
O, and he is a morris man, having performed with local side, Green Man
Alan Johnson.
That would be my vote – back story, hinterland, seems like a decent human being, and I’m even prepared to overlook the mod past.
Big thumbs up for Alan Johnson & a custard pie for Corbyn.
Yes I like AJ too. I also like William Rees Mogg but mainly because he is such a wind up merchant and I can perfectly see why many can’t stand him. I think he’s hilarious.
I don’t think he is a wind up merchant. I honestly think he’s really that clueless.
Do you mean Jacob, son of William.
Oh! Yeah I do. Not sure if Twang does.
No I did mean William.
God I’m having a mare with this. I meant JACOB. Engage brain before posting. It was great watching that pompous ass Evan Davis barraging him with evidence from experts and JRM rendering him speechless by saying “these people are little more that star gazers and soothsayers”.
I can’t bring myself to hate Ken Clarke
Good call. Top bloke.
Seconded.
Thirded
Yeah I really like KC. Super principled over the EU thing and was basically the unofficial opposition during that shameful Article 50 bill carry-on.
Fourthed…very sound on jazz, wears suede shoes (the mark of a bounder) and the only Tory left with any principles.
It’s nice to see Ken Clarke still in rude health, about 30 years after Alan Clark referred to him as “a walking life insurance risk” in his diaries. Ha!
Back in the 90s during my sell-my-soul-to-the-devil-corporate-gigging days in a London hotel, my band was asked to turn down by Ken Clarke (Actually he sent some hotel staff flunky to ask for him). We did NOT turn down (he wasn’t the paying client). I remember inwardly punching the air and exclaiming to myself “YESS… too loud for the Tories”
Annabel Goldie
Was going to say Jo Cox but one person obviously had a problem with her.
I quite like Hillary Benn but not sure everybody else does so will go with Glenda Jackson.
Like Hilary a lot. Strongly dislike Jackson.
I am a fan of Hillary Benn too. When he went up against Osborne in PMQs last year he was a breath of fresh air & did exactly what an opposition MP should do i.e. ask pertinent questions & call them out when they avoid answering. Something that Jeremy Corbyn is woeful at IMHO.
Have you watched PMQ’s recently? Corbyn is doing an excellent job exposing May, particularly on the NHS. She never answers a question, preferring to rely on pre-prepared insults and blaming the last Labour Government for everything, despite her being a member of the government for the last 7 years.
It’s true, he has got better at reading out prepared questions, but it’s taken 18 months so nothing to be proud of really. The Surrey CC leaks were a gift, nothing to do with his leadership.
I’m an ABC but lost a lot of respect for Hilary Benn when he triggered a totally pointless and self-destructive leadership campaign against Corbyn then did not stand himself.
Iain Duncan Smith. No wait, wrong thread.
Are we including dead ones? Churchill?
That Gandhi fella still gets a good rep
Bit of an Alf Garnett wasn’t he?
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-34265882
Didn’t think I’d need rules but I’m going for active in the UK or Trump would win
And it would be the best win ever. Such a big win. Beautiful!
Can’t be arsed to start another thread but are you watching City? It’s funny
I am. Monaco extremely impressive, living up to the rep.
Wow. 3-3
That Falcao could be a player………
I’ll leave the Pep discussion for another day 😉
Mbeppe looks a player, but we knew that, he’ll go for a packet. Bernardo Silva has been the surprise – only 22, didn’t realise he was this good.
I’d be happy enough if I was a city fan – this has been a great game of football, and it’s not over yet. The desire to cut Guardiola down to size is so very, very English.
4-3
Great game and City fans are used to the roller coaster ride.
I know, god only knows what he makes of Otamendi. Stubborn or genius tine will tell
5-3
Pep’s achieved nothing you know – easy to win in Germany & Spain. It’s England, the best league in the world, that counts.
In 14 minutes your view of Monaco and mine of Pep have been made to look ridiculous. Football eh? Bloody hell..
edit that’s Bingos view of Monaco.
Nice try, Dave.
Oh come now @dodger-lane, Bundesliga’s less moneyed but a decent league. Pep made it impossible to hate Bayern for the three years he was there, such was his cultured approach to football and life. Now he’s gone, normality has been resumed.
We’ve done this before @Bingo-Little and my comment was tongue in cheek. Monaco are still a great team and Pep is obviously a great manager. Football is all opinions as last nights game proved. Best game of football I’ve seen in a long time. Let’s pick this conversation up again at the end of the season.
All due respect, Dave – let’s not.
I’m not Guardiola’s mum, and I’m not going to endlessly defend him against all criticism. He’s quite obviously a very very good manager, and he put together the best football team I’ve ever seen. His teams always play on the front foot and I enjoy watching them. That’s about it.
If you want an angle to criticise him for last night you might note that he had his arse saved by a centre forward who, until now, he’s been slowly working out of the club. Beyond that, just happy to watch a really, really good game of football between two sides who just went at each other all night.
All due respect back at ya! Ok fair enough. Fantastic game
Roll on the second leg – has the potential to be another absolute classic!
@bingo-little @dave-amitri as a City fan, certainly the most thrilling game since the Agueeerrrrooooo title winner. Not for one of a nervous disposition, as good though Monaco were (buy Silva to start to replace Silva is an obvs move) Stones and Otamendi were uncomfortable all night. Having a back 3 meant a huge space on the opposite side to where the ball was as the defence shuffled across, which Monaco exploited for the first hour. Can’t believe that CB partnership will start next year. Yes Serge was a leader – even tackling back just outside our penalty area. I think a lot of the Pep easing people out stuff is smoke and mirrors – look at Yaya earlier on in this season, though he was about our most anonymous player yesterday. We are some strange football version of the human centipede at the moment: a forward/MF line that looks irresistible – how good is Sane starting to look – joined to a defence that frequently looks terrified, with neither punting it look or playing out from the back working too well.
Think that’s a good summary.
Thought David Silva was electric in the closing stages, really rolled back the years, and that trio of Sane, Sterling and De Bruyne is superb and will only improve.
Aguero – I said to some mates back in September that I wondered if it would work out for him under Pep – pressing and tracking back aren’t his forte, and that’s what guardiola tends to look for. Last night was the first time this season that I’ve seen Aguero properly adapt his game, and that tackle you mention was an eyebrow raising moment. I harbour a secret hope that we might swap you Sanchez for Aguero, because I think the latter remains the best player in the country.
Can’t speak for Otamendi, but I’ve seen Stones play several times in the flesh, for both yourselves and Everton, and if he’s a centre back I’m a monkey’s uncle. Lovely on the ball, but absolutely no sense of danger (the two may be linked). I suspect you’ll be watching Virgil Van Dijk next season.
Yes the only match we’ve seen live this season was the home match v Soton – went behind to a Stones error. VVD was immense (in all senses of the word). Hope we do get him, though we’ll probably sign 3 more ‘pacy mids’ as my son says instead. Surely even Pep can see something is wrong if he ends up playing Fernandinho at RB.
Re Silva – my son has also never seen a ‘slide-rule’ so beloved of commentators. Can we think of a new metaphor – perhaps that pass was ‘precison laser-guided’
Can’t work out if the Churchill nomination was serious and can’t see it is was vetoed as Man City seemed to take over. But, just in case, I veto Churchill.
Denis Skinner
I did politics A level and my class was being shown around the HOC about 30 years ago by the (now disgraced ex-jailbird) Barnsley MP, Eric Ilsley, when we walked past Skinner in the lobby. He spotted Ilsley and the conversation went “eyup Eric” – “eyup Dennis”. Made me chuckle. Very much doubt a meeting of two Tories bringing up similar greetings.
Apart from one or two from above, I also like Matthew Parris and Sarah Teather, but my favourite was Julian Critchley. Used to love reading anything he wrote.
I was at school with Son of Critchley, which obviously meant he came to school to talk to us.
Funny man, and I thought, quite smart. He had an interesting perspective on the idea that (at the time) the British press were superior to the US counterparts. It was, opined, rubbish, and he proceeded to demonstrate as such.
Interestingly, I think his “pair” at the HoC was The Beast of Bolsover
Matthew Parris? Sanctimonious prick.
I don’t like Skinner at all. Professional northerner and self-caricature. His yawnsome set-yer-watch-by-him schoolboy antics at formal occasions might endear him to some but they just get on my tits.
I am a fan of his but do agree with the self-caricature comment. Unfortunately he has let his outspokenness become his calling card & it has got very tiresome. A pity as it the passion he displays which is lacking from a lot of MPs at the moment.
He’s allegedly a terribly human being but Nicky Soames gives very good twitter and I have found myself warming to him.
In a serious way as well, I’d like to nominate Rory Stewart. When he does Question Time he’s always the sensible guy speaking. A brilliant writer as well. It’s hard to believe he’s a tory.
Is Soames terrible? I mean he had an affair but so do half the population. (I realise this may not be a popular view)
I met NS once in a ‘professional capacity’. Was a toadying creep I thought.
RS has done a few good docs for the Beeb too. I don’t have this tribal thing that Tory = bastard / Labour = lovely caring person. There are both in both camps.
RS has written a couple of very good books about his time in Iraq and Afghanistan and I think he still is involved in charitable work in Afghanistan. I tend to admire this kind of politician who has had some real life experiences and then goes into politics.
Rory Stewart often seems like the token grown-up in the room (“Wait… this guy actually knows what he’s talking about! Geddimouttahere!”). And yes, his programme on the Borders was quite interesting and original.
There’s a few for me.
– Alan Johnson. Reading This Boy is extraordinary, plus he has a sense of humour and seems to like his music.
– Ken Clarke. Thoughtful conservatism.
– George Osborn. I know, I know. He’s a millionaire, part of that awful set and his p.r is dreadful. But I have heard from people who know him what a very nice man he is, genuine and this is from Labour people. I think Teresa May made a huge mistake kicking him out and I credit him for staying in politics post Brexit.
– Matthew Parris. I wish he had stayed in politics.
I find it hard to admire anyone in the current Labour ranks, Corbyn may be a nice man but he’s hopeless and between him and his acolytes he’s going to ruin Labour not only as decent opposition for the next 4 years but as a serious alternative govt.
From the past, I liked and admired Michael Foot, treated shamefully by his own party and the media but a principled and witty speaker.
I have also heard the same thing about George Osborne. A person who would know assured me he was the only non cunt in the entire coalition government.
However he was an abysmal chancellor and he deliberately fucked over poor people. So fuck him.
I’m not so sure Corbyn is very nice. He does a good impersonation of it though.
I’m sure about the same proportion as in any other walk of life are pleasant people. However I think almost all of the rest of them know how to charm.
It’s part of the training they get and an important part of how they persuade people to vote for them come election time, so being pleasant when chatting is not always a guide to true character.
There are some, of course, who cannot muster any charm at all, ever. Even if they try, which a few seemingly do not.
Parris is likeable precisely because he left politics. (See also Portillo). As an MP he was rather pompous. As a commentator he is almost unbeatable.
Both Parris and Portillo vastly improved as human beings by leaving active politics.
As I said earlier, Parris is a sanctimonious prick. Far too self-satisfied.
Cnuts the lot of them.
Alan Johnson was a shite short tem minister of health, so, that and his hair rules him out. As a paradox, Ken Clark, who was a major level cunt as minister of health I admire. Just as a consummate professional politician who has also (his) principles, and could turn his hand to any portfolio, and did.
My favourite was Frank Dobson. Good dude.
I work with MPs and generally find I like them, even the ones I don’t agree with. It’s much harder to hate people once you’ve actually met them. I can think of two though who I thought were really unpleasant, one who was spectacularly thick, lazy and xenophobic (and as such a perfect representative of his constituency) and one who seemed a little bit satanic. One of them’s a Minister now.
Steve Rotherham bought me a sandwich once, so he’s okay in my book. Tuna, it was.
Always remember a mate of mine who was a senior trade union official being completely won over by Cecil Parkinson who he reckoned was a top bloke. Of MPs I’ve met, Andy Burnham always seemed to me to be a good guy and in it for the right reasons. Keith Vaz, not so much.
Didn’t someone say on here ages ago that they met Thatcher and was fully prepared to spit in her face but was completely charmed when she talked to him.
It was probably the Afterword’s very own Zelig, the currently-missing-in-action ianess.
Fancy Keith Vaz turning up on here in any capacity. One of many current MPs who is simply risible.
Steve Rotherham came across as the type of MP we need on that fly on the wall documentary a year or so back. Seemed a very decent sort. The show also helped fill the void created by the death of Brian Sewell, by giving me Jacob Rees-Mogg to take the role of the person most likely to make me put my foot through the telly.
That award goes to Alex Salmond for me. Mute button on sight of his fat face.
Agree about Clarke and Johnson. Of the younger intake Stella Creasey seems like a decent human being. And I know this will be unpopular but I’ve always liked Harriet Harman.
And what about Fiona Davidson – surely everyone’s favourite Tory?
And were he still alive I reckon everyone would go for Charles Kennedy – that was such a sad loss.
Don’t know Fiona Davidson – do you mean Ruth Davidson?
I do indeed – no idea who Fiona is!
Stella Creasy … isn’t she, like, a world authority on top Yorkshire indie band and Peel favourites The Wedding Present? I think she’s written sleeve notes for one of their albums or something.
Harriet Harman seems rather po-faced to me. A bit of a closet spartist.
No sense of fun, I would imagine.
Soft spot for Ken Clarke, David Penhaligon, Frank Field, Alan Johnson, Kate Hoey and Gisela Stewart. I’ve met and worked with one or two over the years. Nice ones included Wayne David (whose brother taught me maths), Tristan Garel-Jones, Hilary Benn and, er, Leon Brittan. Tony Benn seemed decent if flawed – banning pirate radio, going out of his way to dodge inheritance tax and advocating ruinous policies from a position of vast wealth.
Is the Field/Hoey/Stewart thing because of Brexit?
I don’t know much about Gisela Stewart apart from that, but Kate Hoey is awful. If you look at her issue profile the only reason she never stood as UKIP or Tory can only be that in her constituency, they’re only ever going to elect someone on a Labour ticket. I don’t mind people having a different set of views to me but that strikes me as wildly cynical.
God no. I didn’t know FF was pro-Brexit. He – along with IDS (come friendly bombs) is one of the few politicians who’s thought carefully and outside the box on welfare reform, a huge issue in parts of the country like my home town, that both Thatcher and Blair ducked. He manages to rise above the yah-boo nonsense to support things that actually have a chance of improving people’s lives, rather than patronising them and encouraging defeatism. GS always impressive on This Week. Hoey – like most politicians I admire – seems more enamoured of her principles than party line or career.
IDS spent time thinking outside the box – maybe. What he certainly did at the DWP is spend most of his time making life as difficult as possible for the poorest in the nation while living in a free house on his father-in-law’s estate, and lying through his teeth to Parliament. A truly loathsome individual.
Ha! Yes, I suspect we won’t agree Count. It always amazes me that lefties genuinely imagine that their political opponents either don’t care about people or are actively evil. Somewhat adolescent don’t you think?
No. It’s just that so many (not all) on the right care more about money than about people. That is, after all, why they’re on the right.
I don’t agree with that. The people I know who are on “the right” are there because they believe (rightly or wrongly) in self determination over government assistance. They believe that the nanny state approach disempowers people and thrusts them into victimhood. They also believe that if we focus on making our society as a whole richer, the benefits will be felt by everyone.
I don’t agree with all of that, but I’ve certainly not found many people on the right who care about money more than people. They just have a different view of how best to help people.
Well, given the fact that IDS is a demonstrated serial liar, I think questioning his ethical and moral base is very much in place.
There are those on the right we can admire. But for Christ’s sake let hold a standard of decency that means he isn’t one of them.
A politician who doesn’t lie – that’s got to be an oxymoron.
Yes, but his were lies on the Jeffrey Archer/ Paul Nuttall scale. Not about policy (ahem) but about personal achievements and academic record.
Look, fudge facts about policy and data – that’s all in the game. But don’t make bald faced lying statements about yourself. Twice.
I ran a quarter of the London Marathon with Mathew Parris MP but he left me for dead and finished in just over 2:30. He came over and congratulated me when I finished 20 minutes later.
Not a Tory fan but always thought he was a genuinely nice guy & a Hell of a runner.
I have had dealings with Matthew Parris and yes, he is a splendid individual. Genuinely pleasant.
Really enjoyed reading his memoirs too. Worth seeking out if you haven’t read them.
For the third time, a sanctimonious prick.
Norman Lamb. He put money up for his son to start a record label for Grime. Where would Tynchie Stryder or Lethal Bizzle be without him? He also talks good sense on health matters.
I’m warming to David Lammy. He’s stuck to his guns during the Article 50 shitshow.
Not that this has anything to do with anything, but he can really sing too. Some years ago, through a combination of circs to involved to go into, I found myself in a choir backing him when he sang Something Inside So Strong. He aced it.
Caroline Lucas
Ew
What?
He no like.
That’s his loss. I wonder why?
Sanctimonious rentagob whose policies, if ever implemented, would lead to mass impoverishment.
Which policies do you mean? All of them?
Almost all. They largely rely on the magic money tree and are an economically illiterate wish list from people who have learnt nothing from history.
I used to like her but she’s succumbed to generalised project fear lingo. It’s all going to hell in a hand basket, no one voted for this blah blah. I have very mixed and conflicting views on brexit but evidence of a bit of thought rather than headline spouting is what we need at the moment. See also Farron, T.
Paddy Ashdown always seemed a good sort and perhaps the only politician who became more popular after a tabloid expose.
Of the current crop, I like Labour’s Jess Philips.
I always found Paddy Ashdown rather smug.
Certainly agree on Jess Phillips. I also have a lot of time for Sarah Champion.
Unfortunately my local MP, Philip Davies, is one of the nastiest hypocrites currently leaving slime trails all over the back benches.
Oh yes indeedy. Philip Davies is an absolutely wretched person, though he answers his mail which apparently endears him to many of our fellow constituents despite his fondness for filibustering free hospital car parking for carers, a domestic violence bill, and his overt sexism which he portrays as being pro-men (his approach is that men should be dragged down to suffer with the women rather than women raised up to be equal to men).
Talking to Shipley Feminist Zealots on Saturday if you fancy it.
Such a hard question and even harder to answer due to the myriad computation involved.
Living. Barack Obama.
Dead. Benjamin Franklin.
Michael Portillo. There I’ve said it.
Up to a point, Lord Copper…didn’t he redeem himself by losing his seat and turning into a cheery all-purpose telly bloke?
Nope, vetoed. What some people like about him – his telly persona – sticks in my craw. I am shallow, but his ridiculous dress sense and the way he cradles his Bradshaws makes him unwatchable. Also he remains in favour of the disastrous way in which BR was privatised.
“The way he cradles his Bradshaws”. Ooh er, missus.
A former Tory defence secretary – deeply Thatcherite – who goes on telly and says that renewing Trident is a rotten idea and a criminal waste of money: whatever you think of him, a real Through-The-Looking-Glass moment.
Peter Kyle in Hove is a thoroughly good bloke who won the seat from the Tories in 2015. It’s one of only three Labour constituencies south of London and the only gain from the Conservatives. So of course the Corbynists in the local Labour party are trying to get rid of him, so they can lose it again next time.
I like Sarah Champion a lot. Plus Stella Creasy and Jess Phillips. I think in the case of the latter two if you’re getting non-stop crap from SWP misogynists you’re probably doing something right.
Yes I like Jess Phillips. And across the aisle Sarah Wolleston is a good sensible sort.
Ooh yes, Sarah Wolleston is ace. Another Tory who’s doing a better job of opposition than the actual Opposition.
I think of Jess as a smirking opportunist. Rather appropriate that she often takes Diane Abbott’s old seat on Thursday nights.
I find it impossible to dislike anyone who has told Diane Abbott to fuck off.
Abbott is my MP and I get the strong impression increasing numbers of previously Labour voters will be joining the fuck off queue come the next election.
I’m going to take this off in a different direction for a minute. Wouldn’t it be great if we could pick the best from all sides to form a government regardless of which party they represented? It seems to me to be really self harming to have good MP’s as backbenchers just because their party is unelectable. @Chiz made a comment on another thread about the fulcrum in politics and opinion which struck a real chord with me. Maybe we can get Ken Clarke and Co to start The Fulcrum Party and take the best of all parties, it would be like a political Band Aid. (Bad analogy)
No, it really wouldn’t. you need some underlying principles to tie a government together as it affects many many day to day decisions that we never see. For example – in favour of the NHS or not?
MPs are much less aligned to parties than people think. Most of their work is done in cross party committees and APPGs. It’s only the shouty show-off stuff in the Chamber where they have that whipped loyalty to their leadership. Elsewhere they’ll speak for their constituents and from their own experience. Select committees, which hold government agencies to account, are rarely tribal.
I’ll join the Fulcrum party! Although I suspect we may already have it, in the Lib Dems, and no one likes them very much at the moment.
Ha! Let’s do it. The Lib Dems knacker themselves because they won’t admit that the other parties might have a good idea, at least not publicly. The Fulcrum Party would accept that in order to find the true middle ground you have to accept left, right and centre, sometimes….. The Fulcrum Party – “Making Britain Balanced Again” (ok that needs some work…)
I’m a Lib Dem. I don’t think much of Tim Farron but they’re preferable to the others and at heart I’m a liberal. I have a pile of leaflets in the hall to junk mail to the locale later. I think you’d find that in many repeats they do have elements of the other parties but Farron is hardly going to credit either party with anything after the kicking they got for ensuring stable government in the Coalition. Sure they made mistakes, but the alternative would have been tremendous uncertainty at the worst possible time. Sadly our electorate is too immature to understand this.
You say that about the electorate but as we have seen recently if you can truly master the delivery of the message anything is possible. Cleggs meteoric rise proved that he got to the electorate, immature or otherwise, because he understood who he was talking too and how he needed to come across although I suspect it was entirely natural. No one will ever listen to Farron. I happen to think Theresa May understands that and has viewed what has happened over the lsat few years, realises the power is with the electorate and she needs to engage as many as possible. Something Corbyn is entirely clueless about
I agree with all that. By immaturity I mean the reflex hatred of the LDs because they “propped up” the Tories where in fact they drove them spare by muting the more swingeing aspects of what they wanted to do – as evidenced by the amount of complaining the Tories did about them. We appear to be unable to accept that working together isn’t automatically evidence of betrayal of principle. Compromise and finding common ground is what grown ups do.
Total Agreement. Sadly. They went wrong gambling nearly everything on PR voting (when a few minutes of calm thought would have shown Clegg et al that they were being stitched up).
The SNP seem to be managing their (second) stint of minority government.
This approach you’re describing sounds almost like a sort of… third way. Sign me up.
Well, that’s me, you and Chiz. Are you with us @Twang How do you go about registering a political party and what’s our colour going to be? Rainbow has been taken, how about magnolia?
I think the LDs are the third way and I’m already signed up. You can chose the picture on your membership card. Mine has a pair of crossed legs wearing socks and sandles.
It’ll be interesting to see where their position on Europe gets them though – I’m not so sure all the noise about second referendum etc is going to translate to seats.
“Close that stable door!” etc
I think we are actually there – except the coalitions are within the parties. Not sure about the LDs, but there are at least 2 Labour parties slugging it out in the PLP and country, and 2 Tory parties doing the same less publicly. Realistically both of the could/should/would split if it did no mean electoral wilderness – and I’m not convinced they wont.
Well there’s a theory that the centre left from Labour and the centre Right from the Tories should form a new party leaving the hard left/right lot to their own devices.
I’m prompted to add that the single politician i found myself agreeing with the most, in government and out, was the late Robin Cook. Not universally popular, due to his irritating habit of being right.
His autobiography was an unexpectedly cracking read. I was expecting deeply thoughtful political musings but it’s actually quite easy and breezy. Very funny in parts too – he has a story where Tony Blair has a meeting with him in the Downing Street garden on a sunny day – as they walk around, Blair keeps moving them towards the sunshine, Cook keeps steering them back towards the shadows as Cook was prone to instant sunburn. The meeting was about something important but this subtle, unspoken power play between them was the main thing he remembered.
Agree, look at the Labour Party now and think about the people they had, ooh, say in the late 90s.
A terrible bighead. But very funny and very very clever. A sad loss to public life.
Why single out Labour? The landscape is not crowded with political giants.
Chris Mullin.
Another Chris:
Chris Smith
He always seemed OK. Is he in the House of Lords or something now?
Doh ! Slaps forehead, of course. I went to hear CM promote one of his books, very witty and actually answered awkward questions. Plus his thrillers are great reads.
Yes, I always liked Chris Mullin. His book ‘View from the Foothills’ about the absurdities of being a junior minister in the Blair years is a great read.
Another up for Mullin. Largely on the side of the angels.
Yes, as is the sequel. His take on Blair and Brown is interesting. He clearly loved Blair but thinks he got his one big thing (Iraq) horribly wrong, whereas he loathed Brown but credits him with getting his one big thing (averting global economic meltdown) right.
His books are examples of where the audio is just as good (if not better) than the written version (see also Danny Baker , Partridge etc.)
While we’re on politics, anyone want to predict tomorrow’s by elections?
Stoke – Labour, because Nuttal’s a fantasist
Copeland – Tory, because Corbyn’s anti-nuke
Hostage to fortune, anyone?
One thing’s for certain – that by-election is the biggest thing to hit Copeland since Morrissey unexpectedly played Whitehaven Civic Hall on his 2006 UK tour.
I lived in Workington then & couldnt get a ticket, it sold out virtually instantly & by all accounts it was brilliant.
Whitehaven civic was also where I saw the worst gig I ever went to.
Spiritualized – ladies & gentlemen, we are floating in space.
Or as the people of West Cumbria renamed it “Ladies & gentlemen we are leaving in droves” – Maybe I caught them on a bad night, but trust me, they were fucking dreadful.
Politicians? – I always liked James Callaghan & Dennis Healey.
Callaghan seemed to me like a bumbler who failed completely to keep it together as PM.
Healey was a devious, adaptable and extremely clever cove who probably would have done well in Michael Foot’s place.
Unfortunately he was seen as too tricky by the party hierarchy. They didn’t trust him to protect their interests, so they made sure he lost out to Foot.
I wonder whether the Tories might squeak Stoke – clearly pro hard-Brexit, but without the Nuttall element. The subject of Corbyn is poison on the doorstep at this point, I would’ve thought.
@friar they are nowhere in Stoke, neck and neck UKIP and Labour for the seat. They’re part of a coalition controlling the council with UKIP and independents.
Ah I wasn’t aware. Just going on the basis of how much of a kicking Nuttall has been taking lately, I thought perhaps the UKIP support might switch to another pro-Brexit party.
More likely just not to vote.
Dudes, don’t dismiss The Incredible Flying Brick.
Just finished Gyles Brandreth’s book, ‘Breaking The Code’, about his time as an MP and Whip between 1992 and 1997. Whatever you may think about the Brandreth, it’s a fascinating read and full of wonderful gossip and anecdotes. Pretty much confirms the general view of Ken Clarke but waspish about Harriet Harman and a whole lot of lesser Tory and Labour MPs.
Sarah Champion.
I have no idea what she stands for, but that grey streak is dreamy.
Question I’ve been wondering about for a while – if there was a General Election tomorrow, who would you vote for?
Not “is there a party you like” or “none of the above”: actual, for reals General Election at what looks like a critical moment in British history. Who do you vote for?
Lib Dem.
Does any party want to not renew Trident? If so, them.
Surely the Greens don’t want to renew Trident.
I’d vote Labour. But you guessed that. Though I might be tempted by the “Anybody but Philip Davies please” party.
I’ve worked in a job where I was often in Parliament and rubbed shoulders with a few MPs, and have to say that most are very likeable face-to-face. I’ve got a theory that many become disagreeable twats when they appear on TV/radio and have to press their party line.
That being said, even when he was doing his party duty on the box I always liked our former MP Simon Hughes, and have a lot of time for Alan Johnson.
Don’t agree at all with choice of Corbyn; think he shows an appalling combination of ignorance and arrogance.
Spot on about Corbyn ; add “truculence ” when having to speak to a non-sycophant
Non sycophant addressing Corbyn is called harassment in his brave new world. And he should know given his oay days from the Russian and Iranian state media.
Hughes is an animal rights nutter, so can fuck right off.
I may be a little off-beam here, but didn’t Simon Hughes get elected by running a pretty vicious campaign against Peter Tatchell, highlighting the latter’s homosexuality in a traditional working class community. I remember it being very nasty and then a few years later Simon Hughes came out as gay when it was o.k to do so.
Most of the homophobic poison in that byelection was put out by other sections of the Labour party getting behind a guy they claimed was a ‘Real Labour’ candidate. If Hughes was guilty of anything at the time it was not speaking out against it.
His LibDems colleagues in the area have not always behaved honourably; but he’s not the only decent MP who has found himself with some scuzzy colleagues at constituency level.
Thanks for clearing that up, had forgotten about Real Labour and Bob Mellish.
I think that’s a revisionist view of how the Lib Dems behaved in that byelection. The idea that they were the entirely innocent and bewildered recipients of a homophobic vote is risible.
That was my experience from living next door to the constituency at the time. Maybe the LibDems were making some dodgy comments on the doorstep, but it was the ‘Real Labour’ crowd who were were being loudly homophobic.
Mhairi Black really impresses me. Every time I have heard her speak I have felt that she covers all angles of what she is saying & does so in a very measured way. She also has pointed out some of the hypocrisy of certain policies which I find very refreshing.
I do have a bit of an issue with someone as young as her being an MP. Only because I wonder how much a lack of life experience would impact on her beliefs. (i.e. not having a career prior to becoming an MP / buying a house / travelling etc.) I know that sounds particularly patronising but it is not meant to be.
I have had some correspondence with Jake Berry a Conservative MP in Lancashire. He is definitely a bell end of the highest order. His actions do not match how he votes, he likes to come across as very caring etc. but will then vote for policies that will impact his constituents negatively.
Haven’t actually heard much from her – seems to have kept a low profile since the election. A bit disappointing really.
My local Conservative MP, Richard Harrington, is from the same mould as Berry by the sound of it.
He works hard on constituency business etc. and comes across as caring and pleasant and so on but never goes against the party whips or voices dissent when it comes to voting in the house. Likes to attach himself to local issues whether invited to or not. Especially if there’s some press in the offing.
Was against Brexit but did not exert himself particularly in support of his view. Probably because he knew local opinion was marginally Pro-Brexit.
Michael Fabricant, Micky Fab to his yaysayers, Flabbycunt to his naysayers, is my MP. Disagree bigtime with him on BREXIT, he being so excessively pro-exit as to resign his tory whip on principle when it was first aired by Callmedave, which at least displays principle. but he is otherwise a decent if eccentric dude who genuinely puts Lichfield first, forever bigging up local hospitals and curry houses in Parliament. Plus he is always a visible presence in the city, whether shopping or just being out and about. One of the few tories whose share of the vote kept on rising during the New Labour experiment. Of course I have never voted for him, but I have been tempted.
O, and he is a morris man, having performed with local side, Green Man
“He is always a visible presence…” well, he would be there. You can see that quote hair unquote from the moon.
I interviewed him once. Kept expecting the hairpiece to jump off his head and scuttle out of the room.
He looks like the Justin Hayward in a cruise-ship Moodies tribute act.