3 years after moving back to 363 Oxford Street, apparently soaring Rent Demands will see them leave again.
To be honest, am left quite cold in HMV and rarely find what I’m looking for
(and when I do, my brain usually reminds me that I’ve seen it cheaper on-line)
But … like the ravens at the Tower Of London, Oxford Street should have an HMV Shop
https://www.musicweek.com/labels/read/hmv-to-close-flagship-oxford-street-store-once-again/095220

From experience of my nearest branch, cds are ridiculously overpriced and the selection is very limited compared to what it used to be and relegated to the back of the store. Seem to be more interested in flogging t shirts and toys these days.
Somewhere between “very limited”, “very predictable”, and/or “non-existent”.
“Overpriced” is a given – Cherry Red Box Set, £35+ in HMV, 5 or 6 quid less online or direct from Cherry Red.
HMV was the goto (or the London flagship was) for back-catalogue/not easy to get stuff.
Music though is a secondary product (or so it seems when I go in there) to T-Shirts, Books, PopHeads, and DVDs
There’s a reasonable record shop downstairs staffed by people who seem genuinely into music. Lots of cheap hi fi and a good selection of box sets. Upstairs, the DVD/bluray selection is also pretty decent. But the ground floor is appalling.
Still, it’s a shame – it was a grisly “American Candy” store before HMV Mk, 2 and now will probably go back to being one.
It’s hard to escape the feeling that HMV are still living on borrowed time. They’ve done well to reopen most of their shops near me that closed as part of the last receivership, but all have been rebranded as ‘The HMV Shop’ and are very uninviting stores, chock full of cheap looking merch, but a very limited selection of music and films. I use HMV online a fair bit but seldom visit their stores any more. The last time I was in the Oxford Street shop I was surprised at how shallow their back catalogue was compared to the glory days. Nevertheless, I hope they do find new premises at a less exorbitant rent.
Do my periodic trip upto Berwick Street, just up the road, and its much better, given up on HMV, prices are astronomic. Makes no financial sense to go in there.
Have a HMV in my town and again, its a 30 second drive by at best. Nothing to find, occasionnally a sale but again, you only really find bargains from them online when they or amazon price match the other. That never translates to their stores, hence making it a pointless visit,
It is clearly cheaper and more convenient to source music online. As a business model it seems to make more sense to make the most of the physical space to provide an experience – listening booths, a cafe, separate genre themed rooms with scheduled DJ sets, associated merch and music on display for perusal and purchase, opportunities for punters to play their own curated playlists. Give a musical reason for wanting to come in, not just soulless racks of stuff.
Around 1987 0r 1988 I was visiting the Polytechnic of Central London as a precursor to getting a place there for a diploma/degree in Food Science. I already had another place pretty much in the bag back in Devon but it seemed like a nice day out in the big city. I sat through the various presentations and then a group of around 20 or 30 was taken on a tour of the facilities. At some point I lost all interest and sneaked out through a side door and headed to HMV. I think that was the last time I ever set foot in the place.
I was in there the first Saturday morning after the Band Aid single was released (December 1984). It was heaving. The Yuppie bloke in front of me bought 50 copies and handed 49 of them back for resale.
I think I was buying an import copy of Stop Making Sense at the time, as the UK release was months later.
I don’t think I went back there once the big shop nearer Oxford Circus (where the indoor market had been) in, (apparently), 1986.
I do some voluntary work in Luton and there’s an HMV in the mall there. Generally I don’t buy anything despite wandering around regularly but I did find something I wanted on the website and collected it there which worked quite well. The shop is a mess and at least half of the square footage is given over to crap of no interest to me whatsoever.
Back in the day, when I used to go to That London regularly for one reason or another, a pilgrimage to that HMV was always something to get excited about. The music selection was massive, and much larger than anything in my neck of the woods. I would come away every time with a few treasures that made the trip worthwhile.
Now I wouldn’t bother making any effort going to the Oxford St store, based on my experience with my local HMV: a ground floor dominated by teen-focused merch and K-pop that doesn’t interest me (and never seems to be bought by its target audience either – do teens even go into HMV anymore?), with the back given over to DVDs/Blu-Rays that are only good value when HMV has one of its increasingly infrequent sales.
Upstairs contains an ever-expanding vinly section that I ignore completely as I gave up vinly years ago and don’t miss it at all, and CDs that generally are a bit more expensive than Amazon – although there are sometimes bargains to be had, even though the overall selection is getting smaller and more mainstream (and therefore of less interest to goth-, darkwave-, and industrial-loving me).
I feel like I should support HMV because it will leave a gaping hole in the high street if it goes, and buying online will never feel quite as nice as finding a sought-after item and holding it in your hand, but lately the firm hasn’t made it easy.
I dropped in last year during a quick London visit and picked up a couple of Bruce Hornsby cds. It was a handy location if I had 30 minutes to spare. My one and only visit to the Dublin store since it reopened left me baffled as I could find very little music but lots of merch.
I must confess that the last time I went to a big music store in London, enjoying that fluttery feeling in my stomach as I climbed the tube stairs to street level, dismissing the distressing mental images of the penniless impecunity that threatened to overwhelm me within half an hour, was when I was headed to the mighty Tower at Piccadilly Circus. God, what a temple of delights that was.
We go to Manchester fairly frequently and Fopp is always worth a visit, has a nice vibe and I usually come away with a couple of CDs from the never-ending shopping list. They appear to have a better balance between vinyl, CD, DvD/Bluray, books (always only discounted) and merch. Not as cheap as they were, the days of endless 2.99 jazz CDs are sadly gone.
i miss Fopp in the glory days, the £5 cd bonanza. Picked up both Cannabalism 1 and 2 by Can for £5 each. Load of bargains. I still go in the covent garden one occasionally but its become less essential. Always a more fun place to visit but its been swallowed by HMV.
I remember the first time I walked out of Earlham Street without buying anything and it felt a bit odd, like just before you realise that you’ve left something on the bus.
My feelings exactly.
I might be wrong, but I was unde rthe impression that the reason wasn’t poor sales – which were healthy – but more the landlord raising the rent higher than they could accept.
If it were a sales issue, I doubt they’d be looking for physical footprint.
I worked in central London in the 1980s – what a time to be alive, with 2 huge HMVs, Virgin, Tower and all the backstreet record shops to discover.
It was depressing a whole ago to go into the Exeter HMV and see a sign pointing upstairs to ‘’Music and Vinyl”.
A little applause from me for HMV: the only record and film shop left in my hometown, albeit better for browsing Blu-rays than music, but more fun than online shopping, and an incentive to go into town. The Oxford Street store was admittedly a bit disappointing (no Husker Du albums?), but I understand the closure is due to rapacious landlords
Gotta keep those BVI LLPs afloat with some cash income! Greed is great!
Still bear a grudge with HMV after they went into administration and wiped out any points accrued on their loyalty scheme. The few years before their financial meltdown, and built up a huge amount of points – as I built up my record collection.