The Afterword

Musings on the byways of popular culture

Menu

Navigation

You are here: Home / Forum / Desert Island Bands

Desert Island Bands

by 79 Comments

You are on the island with the books.

You also get to choose the whole recorded work of three bands/artists.

How would you choose?

2

Comments

    • We are all different and nobody is “right” but if my Desert Island played only your three choices on constant repeat, I’d walk naked into the surf and say “it’s been nice but now I have somewhere to go”.

  14. Tonight

    Neil Young
    David Bowie
    Beatles (inc solo)

    No wait

    Stones
    Van the Man
    Kinks

    Oh hang on

    Broooce
    Wilco
    Bob Dylan

    (Edit) how could I forget The Beach Boys?

  15. At this very moment it would be….

    1. Kate Bush
    2. Steven Wilson (as its whole recorded work it would include all the Porcupine Tree stuff as well – that’s at lot of music to keep me going)
    3. XTC

    If I could sneak XTC under the SW umbrella through his remixes, then would be Pink Floyd or Genesis at #3

  20. I’ve got my faves firmly lodged in me noggin, so maybe it’ll be good to hear stuff from those I quite like from the little I have heard and have an appetite to hear more.

    The Fall
    Jake Thackray
    Philip Glass

  25. Van der Graaf Generator (preferably including Hammill’s solo albums)
    King Crimson (preferably including Mr Fripp’s solo and offshoot albums)
    Miles Davis

    …and Ella Fitzgerald for bedtime listening.

    I haven’t included any classical composers or material, trying to stick to the spirit of the OP – but arguably there’s a parallel thread (what three composers’ complete works, maybe?)

  28. Jonathan Richman including the Modern Lovers stuff

    Brian Eno plenty of variety and moods there.

    David Byrne including Talking Heads and other collaborations.

  32. Difficult one as so few artists are consistently great across their careers. Pushed, it would be these and I’ll put up with the odd downside

    Steely Dan
    Beatles
    Bowie

    If I could choose a time range from the artists i.e. a run of their albums, I’d be hard pushed not to include Little Feat somehow

  36. On the basis that I’d want music that cheered me up and gave me the energy that comes through dancing, my first two choices would be New Order and Systema Solar.

    For length of catalogue and having a complete challenge of new language to become familiar with, the 85 albums of Fairuz would take some beating.

  37. Bob Dylan
    Van Morrison (who seems to be getting a lot of votes here)
    And to contrast, The Beatles or The Stones. Oh Ok, The Beatles it is.

    Alternatively Beethoven, Shostakovich and Mozart would keep me occupied.

  40. Every record that the following have played on please:

    1. Crosby, Stills, Nash, Young & McCartney
    2. Greg Leisz
    2. Leland Sklar
    3. Bill Frisell

    Plus, if I may, a smuggled copy of Jimmy Giuffre’s “The Train & The River” – altho’ I assume there will be no customs queues on the shores of the island.

  41. It’s tricky!

    1. The Church (Predictable I know but they do have an extensive back catalogue.)
    2. Sparks. See above
    3. The Fall. See above, see above.

    I was out on Saturday listening to a John Robb talk which was fun. Second part of the talk was a chat with Paul and Steve Hanley which was equally excellent. It reminded me that, while some of my most fun gigs were watching the Fall, I don’t actually have that many of their albums in my ‘collection’ so this isolation would be a good time to remedy that.

    Hang on, a reserve choice, The Chameleons.

  43. Predictably enough for here:

    Dylan
    Teenage Fanclub
    My heart says Felt

    But my brain says Brian Eno, plus collaborations and productions, because I could no doubt do with the occasional change from the strummed guitars of the first two, plus there’s a hell of a lot of it, much of which I haven’t actually heard yet, so that’d be nice.

Leave a Reply