Results in the comments. Just over 100 albums/collections nominated. Naturally as it is Christmas Eve I am three sheets to the wind so apologies for any errors/omissions.
Comments
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Musings on the byways of popular culture
by dai 17 Comments
Results in the comments. Just over 100 albums/collections nominated. Naturally as it is Christmas Eve I am three sheets to the wind so apologies for any errors/omissions.
You must be logged in to post a comment.
dai says
Here is your Top 13, these are the entries that got more than one nomination. A strong top 3 I believe even if The Fabs effort is middling compared to other box sets of theirs.
1 The Beatles – Revolver SDE (32 points, from 10 votes)
2 Wilco – Yankee Hotel Foxtrot SDE (23, 6)
3 Pink Floyd – Animals Remix/SDE (22,6)
4 Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers – Live at the Filmore 1997 (17,4)
5 Little Feat – Electrif Lycanthope (16,5)
6 Dexys Midnight Runners – Too Rye Aye remix (12,4)
7 Manic St Preachers Know Your Enemy Deluxe ((11,3)
8 Plainsong – Following Amelia (9,3)
9 Various – We are the Children (8,2)
9= Various – Fell from the Sun (8,2)
11 Dennis Bovell – The Dubmaster (7,3)
12 Rolling Stones – Live ast the El Mocambo 1977 (6,2)
13 Various – Now 12 inch 70s Collection (5,2)
Vulpes Vulpes says
Nice. A lot to like in that lot. Great work @dai!
Tiggerlion says
Great work, dai. The Revolver box may not be quite as good as the previous boxes but the remix is right up there with the best. I spent nearly three hours in a car yesterday and it sounded wonderful, including She Said She Said, which takes some getting used to under headphones.
dai says
Thanks. Remix love not universal, our Irish friends that run a podcast don’t like it, I like some of it, but should give it a few more listens. Haven’t really listened to the set since it came out which seems to be typical for me
dai says
And here are the remainder, generally artists only straight from my spreadsheet:
All except Various – Deep in the Woods (2) got one vote each
14 John Martyn 5
14 Various/jon Savage 5
14 Joni M 5
14 David Sylvian – Blemish 5
14 Charlie Brown 5
14 Blondie 5
14 Count Ossie 5
14 Various – Msuic stars 5
14 Toyah 5
14 Hepworth 5
14 Soft Machine 5
14 Bert Jansch 5
14 Robert Fripp – Exposures 5
14 David Sylvian – Sleepwalkers 5
14 Various – Summer of Soul 5
14 Sun Ra 5
14 Blondie – Against the Odds 5
14 Sammi Smith – Looks like Stormy Weather 5
32 Keef Hartley 4
32 Broadcast 4
32 Various – End of the Road 4
32 House of Love 4
32 Neil Young – Time Fades Away 4
32 VDGG 4
32 Various – Crossroads Kenya 4
32 Pearls before Swine 4
32 Lovey’s Band 4
32 Marc Almons/Chris Braide 4
32 Curtis Lee 4
32 The Yabby You Sound 4
32 The sunshine Worl of Louis Philipps 4
32 Danny Zeitlin 4
32 Zappa – Waka/Wazoo 4
32 Orbital – 30 Something Years Later 4
32 That Petrol Emotion – Every Beginning 4
32 Bill Evans – You Must Believe in Spring 4
50 Stereolab 3
50 David Sylvian – Manafon 3
50 Gotta get a good thing 3
50 Electrif Lycanthrope 3
50 Miles Davis 3
50 Nancy and Lee 3
50 Jethro Tull 3
50 Love singles 3
50 Various – The Virginia Box 3
50 Iris DeMent 3
50 Various – the Meaning of Within 3
50 Los Kenya 3
50 Divine comedy 3
50 Various – 1979 3
50 Various – 1980 3
50 Various – Riding the Rock Machine 3
50 Various – Kids on the Street 3
50 Zappa – The Mothers 1971 3
50 Beach Boys – SAIL 3
50 Neil – Toast 3
50 Richard Thompson – Guitar/Vocal 3
50 Roxy Music – Best of 3
50 Senseless Things – First of Too Many 3
50 Dusty Springfield – Sings Soul 3
74 Various – Deep in the Woods 2
74 Neu 2
74 Pink Floyd Pulse 2
74 Mavis Staples and Levon Helm 2
74 The Movers 2
74 Various – Paul Hillery presents 2
74 Kraftwerk Remixes 2
74 Tom Waits – Alice 2
74 Various – Ost-Kraut 2
74 Wganda Kenya 2
74 Frank Sinatra Watertown 2
74 Zappa – Zappa ’75 2
74 Bowie – Divine Symmetry 2
74 Blue Notes for Mongezi 2
88 Fell from the Sun 1
88 Silberland 1
88 The Pretenders 1
88 Now Yearbook 108* 1
88 Emahoy Tsegue-Maryam Guebrou 1
88 Gil Scott Heron 1
88 Bernard Butler 1
88 Pentangle 1
88 King Crimson 1
88 Richard Gibbs 1
88 Monkees Headquarters 1
88 Orchestre Les Volcans Du benin 1
88 Zappa – Zappa/Erie 1
88 Lee “Scratch Perry” 1
88 Various – Clowns Exit Laughing 1
fatima Xberg says
The remainders list – whoever put that together (Mr. Excel?) surely already had a few…
Who are »Electrif Lycanthrope« ? A Little Feat tribute band?
And since we’re at it, who’s »Fell From The Sun«?
And Neil? Is it the bloke from »The Young Ones«? (Toast doesn’t sound very Prog, no?)
I suppose »Joni M« is a typo for Boney M. But which album??
dai says
Er Neil Young (and Crazy Horse actually), Joni’s is the Archives vol 2
So I think Little Feat actually made 4th place, sorry. Blame it on those who couldn’t follow basic instructions (artist first)!
Vulpes Vulpes says
‘Fell From The Sun’ is the 98 bpm various artists compilation (a Stanley & Wiggs collation) of downtempo stuff from 1990/1991 that also came equal 9th in the top 13!
And most entertaining it is, too.
Baron Harkonnen says
You may wish to expand the `Reissue Poll` to 20 nominations, or you may not @dai.
I say this not as a criticism but due to the number of reissues, historical releases that are released these days. It would make the poll results much more interesting and more accurately reflect the tastes of the pollsters.
Alias says
Thanks for doing this. It’s a great way to discover reissues that went under the radar.
fatima Xberg says
—————
Slight Return: Civilians Edition
—————
1 The Beatles – Revolver (5 CD set) (32 points, from 10 votes)
2 Wilco – Yankee Hotel Foxtrot (8 CD set) (23, 6)
3 Pink Floyd – Animals (Remix) (CD/DVD/BR set) (22, 6)
4 Tom Petty & The Heartbreakers – Live At The Filmore 1997 (4 CD set) (17, 4)
5 Little Feat – Electrif Lycanthope (16, 5)
6 Dexys Midnight Runners – Too-Rye-Ay, As It Should Have Sounded (3 CD set) (12, 4)
7 Manic Street Preachers – Know Your Enemy (3 CD set) (11, 3)
8 Plainsong – Following Amelia: The 1972 Recordings & More (6 CD set) (9, 3)
9 V/A – Paul Hillery Presents – We Are The Children Of The Sun (8, 2)
9 V/A – Fell From The Sun: Downtempo And After Hours 1990-91 (8, 2)
11 Dennis Bovell – The Dubmaster: The Essential Anthology (2 CD set) (7, 3)
12 The Rolling Stones – Live At The El Mocambo 1977 (2 CD set) (6, 2)
13 V/A – Now That’s What I Call 12* 70s (4 CD set) (5, 2)
14 John Martyn – The Apprentice (4 CD set) 5
14 V/A – Jon Savage’s 1977-1979: Symbols Clashing Everywhere (2 CD set) 5
14 Joni Mitchell – The Asylum Albums (1972 – 1975) (4 CD set) 5
14 David Sylvian – Blemish 5
14 Vince Guaraldi Trio – A Charlie Brown Christmas (4 CD/BR set)) 5
14 Count Ossie – Grounation: The Mystic Revelations Of Rastafari (2 CD set) 5
14 V/A – Music For The Stars (Celestial Music 1960-1979) 5
14 Toyah – Anthem (3 CD/2 LP/7“ set) 5
14 V/A – David Hepworth’s Deep 70s: Underrated Cuts From A Misunderstood Decade (4 CD set) 5
14 Soft Machine ~ Bundles 5
14 Bert Jansch – At The BBC (8 CD set) 5
14 Robert Fripp – Exposure (25 CD/3 DVD/4 BR set) 5
14 Robert Fripp – Exposure (Fourth Edition) 5
14 David Sylvian – Sleepwalkers 5
14 V/A – Summer Of Soul (…Or, When The Revolution Could Not Be Televised) 5
14 Sun Ra & His Arkestra – The Futuristic Sounds Of Sun Ra 5
14 Blondie – Against The Odds 1974 – 1982 (8 CD set) 5
14 Sammi Smith – Looks Like Stormy Weather 1969-75 5
32 Keef Hartley – Sinnin’ For You: The Albums 1969 – 1973 (7 CD set) 4
32 Broadcast – BBC Madia Vale Sessions 4
32 V/A – End Of The Road Presents Between The Music Vol. 1 (2 CD set) 4
32 House Of Love – Burn Down the World 4
32 Neil Young – Time Fades Away 4
32 Van Der Graaf Generator – Interference Patterns: The Recordings 2005 – 2016 (13 CD/DVD set) 4
32 V/A – Crossroads Kenya: East African Benga & Rumba 1980-1985 4
32 Pearls Before Swine – The Wizard Of Is (2 CD set) 4
32 Lovey’s Band– Encore Lovey! 1912 & 1914 (3 CDs) 4
32 Marc Almond/Chris Braide – Things We Lost 4
32 Curtis Lee – Pretty Little Angel Eyes 4
32 Yabby You & The Prophets – The Yabby You Sound: Dubs & Versions 4
32 Louis Philippe – The Sunshine Worl of Louis Philippe 4
32 Danny Zeitlin – The Name Of The Terrain 4
32 Frank Zappa – Waka / Jawaka And The Grand Wazoo (50th Anniversary Suite) (4 CD/BR set) 4
32 Orbital – Thirty-Something (2 CD set) 4
32 That Petrol Emotion – Every Beginning Has A Future: An Anthology 1984 – 1994 (7 CD set) 4
32 Bill Evans – You Must Believe in Spring 4
50 Stereolab – Pulse Of The Early Brain: Switched On Vol. 5 (2 CD set) 3
50 David Sylvian – Manafon 3
50 V/A – Gotta Get A Good Thing Goin’: The Music Of Black Britain In The Sixties (4 CD set) 3
50 Miles Davis – Big Fun 3
50 Nancy Sinatra & Lee Hazelwood – Nancy & Lee 3
50 Jethro Tull – Thick As A Brick (CD/DVD set)3
50 Love – Expressions Tell Everything: Singles (8×7“ Box Set) 3
50 V/A – The Virginia Box: 1950s & 1960s Oddball Labels from Virginia & West Virginia (4 CD set) 3
50 Iris DeMent – Infamous Angel 3
50 V/A – Mojo: The Meaning Of Within 3
50 Los Kenya – Siempre Afro-Latino 3
50 Divine Comedy – Charmed Life: The Best Of The Divine Comedy 3
50 V/A – 1979: Revolt Into Style (3 CD set) 3
50 V/A – 1980 Brand New Rage (3 CD set) 3
50 V/A – Riding The Rock Machine: British Seventies Classic Rock (3 CD set) 3
50 V/A – Kids On The Street: UK Power Pop and New Wave 1977-1981 (3 CD set) 3
50 Frank Zappa – The Mothers 1971 (8 CD set) 3
50 The Beach Boys – Sail On Sailor (6 CD set) 3
50 Neil Young & Crazy Horse – Toast 3
50 Richard Thompson – Guitar/Vocal 3
50 Roxy Music – Best of Roxy Music 3
50 The Senseless Things – First Of Too Many 3
50 Dusty Springfield – Dusty Sings Soul 3
74 V/A – Deep In The Woods: Pastoral Psychedelia And Funky Folk 1968-1975 (3 CDs) 2
74 Neu! – 50 (5 CD set) 2
74 Pink Floyd – Pulse (2 CD set) (2 DVD set) (2 BR set) 2
74 Mavis Staples & Levon Helm – Carry Me Home 2
74 The Movers – Vol 1 : 1970 – 1976 2
74 V/A – Paul Hillery Presents Folk Funk And Trippy Troubadours Vol. 1 2
74 Kraftwerk – Remixes (2 CD set) 2
74 Tom Waits – Alice 2
74 V/A – Ost-Kraut Vol. 1 & 2 (2x 2 CD sets) 2
74 Wganda Kenya – Wganda Kenya 2
74 Frank Sinatra – Watertown (50th Anniversary Edition) 2
74 Frank Zappa – Zappa ’75: Zagreb / Ljubljana (2 CD set) 2
74 David Bowie – A Divine Symmetry: The Journey To Hunky Dory 2
74 Blue Notes – Blue Notes for Mongezi 2
88 V/A – Silberland Vol. 1: The Psychedelic Side Of Kosmische Musik 1
88 The Pretenders – The Pretenders (3 CD set, from November 2021) 1
88 V/A – Now Yearbook 1981, or: 1980 – 1984: The Final Chapter (4 CD sets) 1
88 Emahoy Tsegue-Maryam Guebrou – Emahoy Tsegue-Maryam Guebrou 1
88 Gil Scott-Heron – Pieces Of A Man 1
88 Bernard Butler – People Move On 1
88 Pentangle – Through The Ages: 1984 – 1995 (6 CD set) 1
88 King Crimson – In The Court Of The Crimson King: King Crimson At 50 (4 CD/2 DVD/2 BR set) 1
88 Richard Gibbs – No Use To Grieve 1
88 The Monkees – Headquarters (4 CD set) 1
88 Orchestre Les Volcans Du Benin – Vol. 1 1
88 Frank Zappa – Zappa/Erie (6 CD set) 1
88 Lee ‘Scratch’ Perry – King Scratch (Musical Masterpieces from the Upsetter Ark-ive) (4 LP/4 CD set) 1
88 V/A – Clowns Exit Laughing: The Jimmy Webb Songbook 1
NigelT says
Anyone looking to buy the Revolver CD box set – it’s down to less than £90 on the dodgers site.
fentonsteve says
I think (hope) it will go lower.
NigelT says
I would hope so – I got the 2CD version and thought I might go for the vinyl this time as I already have the mono CD too, but that set is still the same price at the mo.
fentonsteve says
I have the standalone LP which, as usual, was half-speed mastered by Miles Showell at Abbey Road. Hurrah! But then they gave it to bloody GZ to press, instead of Optimal, so it isn’t as quiet as the previous SDEs.
Apparently the mastering across the LPs in the box varies a bit, farmed out to different engineers, due to people catching covid.
NigelT says
Oh crap. The very reason I rarely buy vinyl these days.
Blue Boy says
Excellent job Dai, thanks. Must admit I tend not to check out reissues unless it is an artist I really care about, but these recommendations are making me think again