Venue:
Digbeth Arena, Birmingham
Date: 07/09/2018
I originally only had the one night planned, the 2nd, Garbage, knowing little about Matt Johnson’s The The, beyond Hanky Panky, the Hank Williams covers project, probably somewhat unrepresentative. But @locust had given such a cracking review of her experience a month or 3 back, I felt duty bound to go. And am I glad I did!
Smack on 9.15 and on they/he came, a dapper becapped man of indeterminate and a slew of young turks on supportive roles. Making immediate and ongoing use of back screened video, compelling amalgams of old videos, performance footage and apocalyptic visuals and scenescapes, the sound was crystal clear, vocals fully discernible within the expert mix of guitars and keys. And drums, a terrific bombast to counterpoint the end is nigh atmosphere of the lyrical themes. I didn’t know many of the songs, but I felt I did, so instant were they in their hooks and arrangements, and will be making sure I do know them better in days to come. Given the fact the majority of these songs are up to 30 years old, it seems astonishing how prescient the then themes were, and often, have become prophetic. Presented here, in decaying industrial wasteland, it couldn’t have been a better setting. Highlights were, the names gathered later, The Beat(en) Generation and Armageddon Times Are Here Again, both fairly early in a 90 minute set, but the momentum never really dimmed, the songs becoming possibly mellower as he dipped earlier back into the catalogue. Is his best (known) song Uncertain Smile? Certainly it was a fitting song to end my evening, the first encore as my train was a’calling on me. Fabulous evening.
Roll forward 24 hours, damper inclementude threatening but miraculously holding off, and back again I was. Garbage I am more familiar with, their grungy amalgam of Blondie and Killing Joke always appealing to my ears of 20 years back. This tour, to celebrate the 20th anniversary of Version 2.0, was their first time in Brum since that tour, according to the self-admitted frazzled memory of Shirley Manson, the partisan audience equivalently forgetful. She was a simmering earthquake at the front of the stage, in an uber-pramface hairstyle, shaved at the sides, and an unusual technicolour outfit, one part pacamac, one part binliner over fishnet tights, with an alarming line in crotch and tit grasping. The girl you were warned about at school, secretly fancied but were also, if truth be told, more than a little frightened of. But her voice remains strong, down perhaps a timbre but with foghorn intensity when requited. Because this is, of course, the epitome of any Garbage song, quiet bit, loud bit, quiet bit, loud bit, cacophony. Drummer Butch Vig who, arguably, invented this style in his production duties for Nirvana, remains a solid presence at the back, one of the few cool moustaches in modern times, while the hat one and the bald one look much as they did in their prime, thrashing their guitars and keyboards within an inch of their lives. For live shows they have been, and were tonight, augmented by a very stolid bassist, who perhaps had the most important role on stage, such is the importance of a deep, and I mean deep, underbelly of low rumble in their songs. I have to say their debut was always my favourite, little of this appearing, the meat being, as advertised, the bulk of Version 2, chucking in covers of 13 (Big Star) and snippets of Personal Jesus and Tired of Waiting into the coda of other songs. All the “hits” were played, to rapturous reception, so we got (I Think I’m) Paranoid and their Bond one, otherwise forgotten in the mists, but, if all getting a bit similar, overall it was a first class show. I missed the encore, again mindful of my train. I would have heard it, and I would have liked to, if she hadn’t filled most of the time up to the curfew with a rambling and sweary polemic about her place, and that of the band, in the modern world. It was, apparently, Starman, the Bowie one, but I’m sure it’s on Youtube, given the wall to wall phones picking up every last hic and burp throughout. Two good nights in a row, this perhaps slightly the lesser of the two.
The audience:
Largely similar, Friday perhaps having more grizzled like me, there being a fair proportion of early 40s on Saturday, out on the lash to revisit their youth, babysitters looking anxiously at their watches in the suburbs, no doubt.
A word about the venue. Digbeth ain’t smart, but is trying desperately to hit atrend button. I would say it must be working, as it rises from dodgy to edgy, a bit like a Shoreditch of a decade ago, post-industrial wreckage and ruins housing hipsters and the opportunistic in equal numbers. The “Arena” is what I remember as a carpark, one I was always frightened of leaving a car in, converted with a stage and the use of a roofless warehouse, all crammed alongside and against railway arches to one side. Lots of rubble. Lots of graffiti. But, do you know, it worked and as great. I hope they made some money and can make this Skyline Series, also in Bristol, a success.
It made me think..
I still love live music, me.
(I’m getting mighty sick of our “featured image” police, mind…….)
I’m very glad my review inspired you to go to the The The (no, I’m not stuttering, sir) gig and that you enjoyed it! 🙂 Go forth and seek out ye olde albums (by Ye Ye?), you won’t regret it…
In Yorkshire we call ‘e, T’ T’.
Which would you commend? Dusk looks the most interesting given the evening’s track listing. I have Hanky Panky and Soul Mining.
Dusk is a really good album, go for that. How busy were these gigs? Both acts were also in Bristol this weekend and I get the impression there was a fair bit of papering going on.
Looked/felt pretty rammed, but Brum routinely misses out on many acts these days, in the gap twixt Symphony Hall and the Institute: there are intermediate venues but most bookers seem to go either for for Wolverhampton Civic or miss the midlands out altogether. So the starving masses will come out for those who deign to come. (I don’t count NEC or NIA as Brum as both expensive enormodomes, passion and atmosphere free.)
He’s not been too productive so get Dusk, Infected and Mind Bomb all, they’re all ace!
And get Soul Mining, which contains Uncertain Smile featuring Jools Holland’s best ever piano solo.
And get Burning Blue Soul, which is a kaleidoscopic psychedelic mini-masterpiece with all kinds of groovy tape-loops and unapologetic reverb. Hurrah!
I like Garbage, have seen them thrice, but always preferred Curve who Garbage
ripped off wholesalewere heavily influenced by. I play Curve’s albums more than Garbage’s.I’ve still only seen The The once (at Reading Festival), I must attend to that.
I’m sold – The The at Sydney Opera house in a couple of weeks. I’ll be Billy Nomates since I don’t know anyone else even remotely in to this. Dragging the wife to see David Byrne at the ICC though.
Saw Garbage at Rock City last night. End of the gig more than a little shambolic as Shirley was basically so drunk she could barely speak. Bless her.
I won’t do a new Nights Out for The The, mainly because it was a bit disappointing. Lovely as the Sydney Opera House building and the concert hall are, the atmosphere was flat as a tack. Which is odd, because Neil Finn a few years ago managed to fill the same place with noise and energy. Having seen The The 30 years ago at the Hordern Pavilion when it was a blinder, my inexpert guess is that it was the poor lighting, reliance on the big screen videos behind the band, and comfortable seats for the oldsters wot did it.
That it came over like yet another covers band with the original guy fronting is understandable given the nature of The The, but this guitarist is no Johnny Marr, and the bass player was largely lost in the mix. The keyboards guy did a very accurate rendition of the Jools Holland boogie woogie solo.
All in all, I’m glad I saw him/them in a better setting back in the day…
If he did the same set, it certainly wasn’t designed for comfy seating…..
This seems pretty close to what I remember. But i thought there were only 2 encore tracks.
https://www.setlist.fm/setlist/the-the/2018/concert-hall-sydney-opera-house-sydney-australia-2be904a2.html
In the intro he was very clear (and possibly ironic) stating ‘we are a dance band’, and ‘you can get up’. When the SOH were asked about dancing, he reported their response was ‘if they can’…this may have come up before, given the tendency to grey in the audience. In truth it was a funny mix, mostly 30-60 (with a 10 year old grooving a few rows from me), 40% female, and a surprising and welcome Asian contingent. I don’t know why but I was expecting interest to be a fairly exclusively middle to late aged-white-European-male, just based on the nature of the material.
Damper Inclementude
TMFTL, etc….