Dave Amitri on Low
Month 9 of 12 Bowie Albums in 12 Months. Bloody hell, how did that happen? Three quarters of the way through this dive into Bowie having never listened to one of his albums before. After the high of “Station To Station” the next album “Low” had something to live up to. I try to limit my research as I want to come to these albums as fresh as possible. Coming to this knowing he was off the drugs living in Berlin and experimenting musically was encouraging yet slightly worrying at the same time. What would clean arty Bowie cone up with? Let’s see, or hear, whatever…..
It starts with “Speed Of Life” an instrumental, not the last as I would discover later but with all the build up it’s a pretty basic straight up rock n roll number that does include some Human League style keyboards. I found myself making up lyrics that Mick Jagger might have sung as it reminded me of 80’s Rolling Stones in the style of “Under Cover Of The Night”.
“You done me young you won’t do that twice cos,
I’m moving on at the speed of life.
I won’t be coming round in the dead of night cos,
I’m moving on at the speed of life”
Etcetera. You get the point. It’s ok, but as an opener? I know by now it’s Bowie so I shouldn’t be surprised.
Next up is “Breaking Glass” which I assume Nick Lowe loved the sound of. Not for the first time it reminds me of The White Stripes . Meg’s drumming remains pretty rudimentary. Again there’s some random keyboard thrown in and it finishes pretty abruptly. It’s ok.
“What In The World” takes me back to “Station To Station” and The Associates comparisons again. The mix of keyboards and guitar works really well and it’s a great noise. I like it.
The hit next. “Sound and Vision”. From nowhere it’s one of those great Bowie grooves. The band drive it on and I’m reminded of that clip of Stevie Wonder doing “Superstition “ on Sesame Street with the coolest band you’ve ever seen. Of course it was a hit. It’s another of those ubiquitous Bowie songs that when you really hear it, wow. I suspect somewhere the band is still playing that groove it’s so entrenched. I love it.
“Always Crashing In The Same Car” is a really cool song. I can’t escape the feeling that it’s a little bit Steely Dan but a slightly rougher version, less polished. The guitar in this is perfect for the kind of easy flow of the song. “Whisky In The Jar” like in parts. Following the slightly odd opening this is a strong run of songs.
“Be My Wife” is Chas and Dave meets Van Halen meets The Stranglers. That’s it. I’ve nothing else to say about it.
Typical Bowie fare so far. Eclectic, interesting but no real consistent style. That’s fine, this is David Bowie he’s earned the right to do whatever he wants. Now he does exactly that with 5 almost entirely instrumental tracks. Each one clearly experimental, exploring new ideas and sounds. As always I’ll tell you what I hear, here goes…
“A New Career In A New Town” starts like “Blue Monday” then becomes Madness doing “The Return Of The Los Palmas 7” with plenty of Spaghetti Western harmonica.
“Warszawa” is more Joy Division than New Order mixed with Stings “Russians”
“Art Decade” instantly makes ne think of Japan. It’s another track that in my head I sing in my best David Sylvian voice…
“Art Decade….. (long pause here)
Is it real or an illusion?……(another long pause
Art Decade…..”
Thankfully for us all I can leave “Wailing Wall” be as an instrumental. My first thought was “Tubular Bells” (side 1 obviously…). Then maybe because my Sylvian antenna had been agitated from the depths of my memory I added Sakamoto. I has to go and rediscover “Forbidden Colours” and of course to complete the circle “Merry Christmas Mr Lawrence”. This will be the point at which, Timbar, Tigger or Gary will regail stories of the links. It’s what I’ve enjoyed most about these threads. I hear something familiar and an expert comes along to fill the gaps…
Finally “Subterraneans” in which you can imagine David Attenborough breathily expressing wonder at some creature just discovered at the bottom of the Atlantic. Musically I can imagine Midge Ure belting out “Subterraneaaaaans”. It could on the other hand be one of Mark Hollis’ more esoteric compositions. Whatever it is its a bit lovely with its Gregorian chant / Kenny G sax to close….
So there it is “Low”. It’s a grower, it’s eclectic, it’s Bowie. I have this vision of the recording studio with all these old guitar engineers tripping over wires and extension cables muttering about bloody keyboards while scratching their heads at the noises being called “music”.. Overall for me while I really like it I am left a little frustrated. Why Dave? Well imagine he’d gone all in on the electronica, the ambience, the Neu!? His influence from what he’d heard in Germany is clear but he’s only really committed in parts. It’s importance to the period that followed is clear. That period from 1979 to 1984 that to me is the most exciting, inventive, creative since Chuck Berry picked up his guitar can be traced right back to this along with Kraftwerk I’m sure. If he’d really gone for it in 1976 / 77 “Low” could have been so ahead of it’s time, such a defining work that it could have been discussed in almost Arc of The Covenent terms. After the clear “Station To Station” / The Associates link it will be interesting for me now to find definite references from those early 80s pioneers back to “Low” or at least the parts where he goes all in. Finally I think this album will take me on a Japan/ Sylvian journey that I’ve been meaning to take for a long time.

The great thing about your pieces Dave is that while I know what other people are going to say on these threads – in some cases almost word-for-word – I never know what you’re going to say. You’ve made connections and comparisons that would never occur to us old lightning-flashers (steady).
Interesting views, congratulations on not including the word “Eno” in your write-up
Nor “Visconti”
It’s surely time for this…
No, you should have waited until next month. You’ve ruined everything.
Don’t you realise I’m fucking with the fabric of time?
Arf!
*leaves somebody else to explain the reference*
Low has been in my life for a very long time and I come back to it pretty regularly. The instrumentals are what makes the album astonishing and a reissue also gives us All Saints, which fits in nicely. I’m not sure if I can describe those tracks and do them justice. There’s just such a lot going on and so many noises and patterns that develop. And then on side 1 there’s Be My Wife, which could be in a cheesy Tommy Steele film – and of course Bowie being a pop genius with Sound & Vision. It’s a good square meal of an album. Thanks for writing about it because I’ll be putting it on again soon. I love this record.
Steele’s moody instrumentals with Eno on board sadly remain in the vault
Isn’t Be My Wife the first appearance of his Mockney since Pin Ups?
Think I am in the minority of preferring “Heroes” to Low, spoiler alert @Dave-Amitri, it has an almost identical structure
I think the minimalism on the first side of Low is very clever. Bowie’s vocals on “Heroes” are incredible. The latter is a more satisfying album but I’ve just got to admire the well-I-bet-you-didn’t-see-THIS-coming chutzpah of Low. And it has Sound and Vision on it, which is beyond magnificent.
I’ve got Charles Shaar Murray’s full-page review of Low from the NME and while he’s impressed, he basically gets annoyed with Bowie for being so negative. These are desperate times and you need to give us hope, CSM says: I think it’s pretty odd asking that from Bowie of all people, who had been mining the dark stuff fairly regularly since We are Hungry Men and the like. Ask Bowie to cheer up and you get Dancing in the Street, so think on.
Yes, good points. I love S & V of course. Nice b vocals from Mary Visconti
It was a big hit in the UK partly because it was used as some kind of TV theme and therefore got a lot of free airplay… can’t remember what for. Playaway?
You are Brian Cant and I claim my hamper
Rather than a theme tune, it was used by BBC1 as trailer music – “Coming up later on BBC” This meant that it was played most evenings after Nationwide. (It was just the riff & the “doo, doo, doos” as far as I remember)
That’s bizarrely hip for 1977 BBC1. Would be even now, I think.
I’ve got the single (New Career on the b-side) which is pressed off-centre and is therefore a bit “woozy”. I’ve had it since I was 11 and until I got the Low CD about ten years later i just thought that’s what it sounded like.
It’s very much like Bo Diddley, of course. You could splice it into Who Do You Love no bother.
S&V has a very long intro, which lends itself to being used as a “bed” for coming-up-tonight-on-BBC1 announcements.
I am sure I have heard Weeping Wall as the soundtrack for science-y things as well. Otherwise they use Oxygene Part IV. I can almost *see* Judith Hann when I hear that.
Kraftwerk made an appearance on Tomorrow’s World in 1975, which probably did a lot to get Autobahn into the charts.
Low is a perfect encapsulation of depression. Its soundscape is heavily compressed and difficult to make out individual instruments, almost painful to listen to. There are few words, just over 200 for the whole album, the least on any Bowie album, and unrelentingly miserable: “Don’t look at the carpet, I’ve drawn something awful on it”, “Blue, blue, electric blue, is the colour of my room where I will sit, waiting for the gift of sound and vision”, “Sometimes you get so lonely, sometimes you get nowhere”, “Something deep inside of me, yearning deep inside of me, talking through the gloom”. These words are the voice of experience. CSM suffered with depression himself and would have known this.
Low was recorded in 1976 and released in January 1977 before The Human League was formed. It lit a flame that exploded in New Wave and the New Romantics. It inspired synth-pop and the likes of Joy Division and resonates through most Electronica even today. It is a musical Ark of the Covenant. To my ears, it still sounds ahead of its time.
Great review, Dave, yet again. I think you are going to enjoy all of the last three.
“To my ears, it still sounds ahead of its time” – yeah, because there’s nothing like it – the first side at least. The nearest thing is “Heroes” and that’s actually quite different…. spoiler alert.
Fripp
I would say Heroes is the one where it’s difficult to make out individual instruments. One the main reasons I prefer Low, actually: it’s got an overall cleaner, starker sound. Heroes is extremely muddy and dense.
It’s that the one where he says this album makes you reach up to touch rock bottom?
Next up is “Breaking Glass” which I assume Nick Lowe loved the sound of.
Yep.
It’s a winner!
Great read as always in this series.
I can’t comment on any Sylvian link as I’m not really a fan of Low (post Station to Station it’s only the singles for me). I do definitely prefer Sylvian’s instrumentals to Bowie’s (A New Career In A New Town being the only one I like).
Sound & Vision is stupendously brilliant, mind. Who was it who recommended his friend, the bloke in the video below, for guitar tutorials? Either Tigg or Twang, I think. Anyway, it was a good recommendation cos this video taught me how to play the fiddly bits on S&V.
It was me, actually. Adrian goes from strength to strength, I’m delighted to say, and is closing in on 200,000 subscribers.
Sorry, TrypF, my memory is a tad shite. I knew it was someone beginning with T.
Adrian’s an excellent video teacher. Thanks again for the recommendation.
Hey, here’s a thing (from wiki): The cover artwork, a profile of Bowie from The Man Who Fell to Earth (1976), was intended as a visual pun meaning ‘low profile’. Well I never.
CSM mentioned that in the NME. Apparently it’s the same image from the front of the then-current paperback of The Omi Who Fell to Earth (as I think it was called)
You need to read around these landmark works of art to get them rather than expect to rush through a whole oeuvre and be won over. It’s like going to a Picasso show and saying it’s a bit weird, why does he put both eyes on the same side of the face?
That is a bit weird. Why does he?
To be fair to Dave, he does give each of these albums his full attention, surpassing the six listen rule. I’m sure Bowie would expect his art to speak for itself without anyone being expected to do their homework (though, I’m very much a homework man myself).
But always remember…if the homework brings you down, etc.
Sorry. It all went a bit Paul Morley there. Somebody must have put something in my tea. I wonder just if all responses are equally valid. I mean it depends where you are coming from. I enjoy these pieces though.
It’s all good. I know my limitations, one of the reasons I started this, among many, was to challenge myself a bit. Committing to one a month for a year, knowing that I wouldn’t necessarily like it all, putting it out here among real Bowie fans. I’ve focused almost entirely on the sound and what I recognise in other music. You’re right, I’ve barely touched on lyrics or Bowies state of mind or what it all means. My biggest pleasure has been reconnecting people with these albums and making them hear them through my ears, whether they agree or not. Your Picasso analogy is exactly how I’d react by the way. 😄🙏
Edit.. answer to @Diddley-Farquar
A bit snobby of me though. Emboldened by red wine. The sad effects of the fermented grape.
Low is sometimes my fave Bowie album, although – heretic alert! – I sometimes find myself playing side As of Low & Heroes, and side Bs (or the All Saints CD) when I’m in the mood for instrumentals.
There’s also the “Bowie Now” RSD comp of the albums which is mainly (non hit) vocal tracks I think. I do own it naturally
Isn’t it a reprint of a compo that was doing the rounds (I think in the US) at the end of the 70s? Possibly to go with Isolar II getting over there. I may be wrong.
The Ryko extras from the Berlin albums were a bit tarted up by Bowie in 1990-91 so are possibly semi-authentically from the period at best, which may be why they haven’t reappeared on subsequent reissues. I think that process may be where his experimentalism on the Buddha of Suburbia started to germinate.
Was a promo I think at the time for radio stations and such. Has the recent masterings though from the box set.
Btw I like the versions on Stage too very much.
Stage is bloody good altogether, especially the current version with its corrected running order.
It’s worth seeking out the recording of Montreux in 2002 where they played quite a chunk of Low.
Don’t remind me of that please! I lived in Switzerland and was a frequent visitor to the Montreux Jazz Festival but somehow missed out on that completely
Skip the Ziggy tracks, though.
Standard.
Can’t wait for the Tin Machine 2 Albums in 2 months project Dave
(Arthur Putey voice) In point of fact, there are three Tin Machine albums. The third one’s called “Hunt Sales Ruins Everything, Baby”
Psst.. we’re not including live albums, baby
He said he’s ‘Sorry’, tho. As he bloody well should.
It’s getting a bit Hoffman this.
What are the Dynamic Range numbers? We can’t enjoy listening until we know they are more than 15.
I’m in the dark here. Anyone cate to enlighten me?
https://dr.loudness-war.info/
A database of CD dynamic range created by audiophiles (as if DR was the only factor in sound quality) where 15 is good and 5 is bad.
Oasis score about 5, Metallica’s Death Magnetic (one of the worst-sounding CDs) scores 2.
Hoffmanites stipulate it is not possible to enjoy a CD with a DR of less than 10.
I assume Lark’s Tongues In Aspic Part I is a 50 then.
I see Visions of Autopsy by Rottenbroth did badly. Surprised….
The difference between the loudest bit and the quietest bit. This used to be quite large but has got a lot smaller in the past few years meaning, effectively, everything is the same volume. No dynamics.
DYNAMIC TENSION!
(Bit late to the party) Well done Dave on another great review. For me, it’s fun to find how a fresh pair of ears hears an album I’ve known since its release – I was 14 in 1977, just the age to absorb lots of music & religiously read the music papers.
Bowie had said in an interview in 1976, after the success of Station to Station, that he hoped to release alternate commercial albums “a hit album to make the money to do the next album, which probably won’t sell as well” and once working with Eno, phoned Tony Visconti “We’re trying to combine Brian’s ambient music techniques into writing rock songs.”
The techniques weren’t initially greeted well by all the musicians (“This is bullshit” Carlos Alomar) but the backing tracks were laid down first, before overdubs & finally the vocals were added
.
The presence of Brian Eno hangs heavy, particularly over side 2 – “a lot of people dismissed it as an Eno album…but I put a lot of blood & guts into that album, a fact that tends to be ignored”
There were lots of reports that Side 2 contained music from Bowie’s abandoned The Man Who Fell to Earth score, but apart from a backwards bass line on Subterraneans, none of it was released.
RCA didn’t like what they heard & apparently sent Tony Defries to try & get Bowie to add more vocals (although he’d been sacked as his manager, Defries was still entitled to a 16% share of royalties) – Visconti recounted that “David just looked at the small print of his contract, which read they had to put it out.”
It wasn’t a big hit in the USA, but was successful in the UK – as Tony Visconti said “I’ve got a gold record here somewhere, so it must have sold over a million
Knowing the album so well, I’ve hardly played it in the last 20 years, but giving it several listens over the past few weeks, it doesn’t grab me as much as Station to Station did.
Partly that’s my own familiarity, but also because what were such distinctive sounds, subsequently became common place – The extraordinary drum sounds (What does a harmoniser do, mr Visconti?) were able to be replicated easily with drum machines a few years later.
Having the backing tracks recorded first & then chopping them up & manipulating them is the standard way of working for most dance/pop music (Bowie loved the advent of hard disk recording)
The side 1 songs, with their half formed structures & lyrics, were very influential for punk & post punk musicians, that you didn’t have to conform to “proper music rules” and if it sounds good, then it’s ok.
Because I am very dull, I know what a harmoniser does. It’s a sort of pitch-shifter. Play a note into it and you get a chord out. The genius move of Eno/Visconti was to put it on a drum. The harder Dennis hit the snare, the more it pitch-shifted.
There’s a nice podcast with the inventors at https://www.soundonsound.com/music-business/50-years-eventide-podcast
I think Timbar was referring to Visonti’s “fucks with the fabric of time” quote there.
Yes, but I am very dull.
Despite what Visconti said, Bowie always referred to Low as “the album that didn’t sell”. Until much later.
I hear what you say about Punk. I remember hearing Wire’s first album a couple of years later and dismissing it as a total rip off of side one.
Considering that Low was a deliberately experimental album, that he rejected RCA’s requests to make it more commercial, and rather than publicising it, he backed Iggy Pop on tour, he didn’t do himself any favours.
In the UK, Low reached no 2 & was on the charts for 18 weeks. The following albums charted similarly (Heroes #3/18 wks, Lodger #4/17 wks) suggesting that he retained a loyal fan base for the Berlin albums, but didn’t add to it.
It’s in the USA that he lost the audience, RCA’s (he was signed to the US parent company) long term nurturing, having only paid off with YA & S2S.
Reaching that conclusion must have taken quite a leap of the imagination. 😀 It’s difficult to imagine anything less like it.
p.s. I was replying to Tiggerlion, who said that Wire ripped it off for the first side of their first album. I was expecting the person I was replying to to be inserted automatically.
No mention of Blur ripping off Be My Wife with For Tomorrow?
Or The Police ripping off Breaking Glass for Behind My Camel (or Andy Summers, more specifically)
I was surprised at the way in which Speed Of Life was almost dismissed as filler. I really love that for the way in which it lurches drunkenly and imprecisely through its glorious two minutes and forty-six seconds. I love King Crimson’s Coda: Marine 475 for exactly the same reason.
The Manics used it as “walk on music” when they played all 38 of their hits at the O2 in 2011, it was very exciting (and an amazing 3 hrs concert ensued)